best IPA ever?

We don't get the same range of well-hopped beers in Wisconsin that it seems you can on the coasts, but my favorite hop-babies that we can get locally:

1) Dogfish Head 60 Minute (lush, florid, long, bright, open) 2) Sierra Nevada Celebration (the last batch in particular was broad, supple, and beautiful; not as monolithic as in the past). 3) Dogfish Head 90 Minute (a good, bracing, stiff one). 4) Bell's Two-Hearted Ale (was my fave till the DfH 60 came into town). 5) Victory Hop Devil (solid, enjoyable) 6) Goose Island IPA (a really well-rounded and satisfying IPA from Chicago) 7) Anderson Valley Hop Ottin' (pleasant & flavorful)

IPA's that I've had here but haven't bought again very much because they just haven't been slammin' or enchantin' enough or maybe I should try them again include some great ones, by most measures, including 3Floyds Alpha King, Rogue Brutal Bitter, and Red Seal. I will, though, run out and get the Racer 5, thanks to the recommendations!

Reply to
Douglas W Hoyt
Loading thread data ...

Two of those three are definitely on my list - LaConner and Diamond Knot. Bell's Two Hearted as well. Been eons since I had Town Hall's IPA (assuming you're talking the one in Minneapolis), but it was quite good. Among brewpub IPAs, Big Time in Seattle also has an outstanding one.

-Steve

Reply to
Steve Jackson

I think La Conner's IPA isn't quite the same as it once was, but the brewer who used to brew it is now at Rogue's Issaquah Brewhouse, and when he has occasion to brew a hoppy beer there, it's very good indeed.

Diamond Knot's IPA & Industrial IPA are the same as ever, and now that they have the B2 production brewery running, I expect to see more handles around the region. That won't suck.

Another reliable IPA comes from Boundary Bay. It's one of the permanent handles at my local.

These days, it's more like an outstanding three: Scarlet Fire, Bhagwan's, and Meerkat, and sometimes something else as well.

Reply to
dgs

Dang, that's a good question. None available at BevMo? I don't recall Pike on tap anywhere in the City, but then, there's a *lot* of competition for handles these days. I like all the North Coast beers on at the Hog Island Oyster Bar at the Ferry Building.

Reply to
dgs

"John S." wrote in news:1147032170.811886.250810 @g10g2000cwb.googlegroups.com:

New River Pale Ale is actually an APA (to split a beer-hair). That being said, I'm going to go cry now, as I used to live 15 miles away from Dominion and always had New River in my house as my standard beer. Perfect balance of malt and hops, wonderful mouthfeel, IMO the best beer on the planet pound-for-pound. It's about the only thing I miss from living on the East Coast.

To be local again, I'll vote for Masala Mama from Town Hall in Minneapolis. Brewpub-only, but damn, it's spectacular stuff. Bottled, dunno. Hop Devil, like everything from Victory, seems to have gone downhill in recent years. Maybe SNCA by default as the best.

Reply to
Dan Iwerks

New River is certainly a good APA. I've had it as my home draught beer on a number of occasions, as well as the Tupper's Pils. While solid, at least for as East Coast beer, it's about fair-to-middlin' when compared to a number of West Coast entries. Vinnie Cilurzo's stuff at RRBC comes to mind, as well as the beers Paddy used to brew at Moylan's, and when Marin IPA was on, it was untouchable.

Was just there last Saturday, and things don't seem to have gone downhill in the least. Hop Devil is likely become a victim of palate creep as people titrate up their hop resistance, but it remains largely unchanged from the pilot batches.

With Old Dominion's recent sale, I have to wonder if there'll be some reracking of the lineup and maybe some new products.

Reply to
cg

I just bought it again tonight after the current discussion, and at first it seemed a bit uninteresting, compared to sundry hop monsters and hop flower goddesses. But by the end of the bottle (which was best quaffed quickly for maximum effect) it turned out to be a great, quenching guzzle on warm/humid day.

Reply to
Douglas W Hoyt

I'll drink to that. Actually I enjoy the New River as well as the two Tuppers. Although the Pils would probably rank third of the group in a close race.

Did you ever make it to the pub? Pretty decent food and the freshest beer.

Hehe..

Reply to
John S.

"John S." wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@q12g2000cwa.googlegroups.com:

The Tuppers Hop Pocket Ale was the beer that really hooked me hard as a beer geek. Miss that one as well, but nothing as much as New River.

Dozens and dozens of times. Going to be back out East for a few days and need to make a pilgrimage there. Wondering how many growlers of the brewpub version of Oak Barrel Stout I can get into my carryon . . .

Reply to
Dan Iwerks

"cg" wrote in news:Zyu8g.133$5Z.71@dukeread02:

Definitely a personal preference thing, but I tend to find a lot of West Coast beers fall prey to the usual West Coast stereotype of unbalanced towards the hop side of things. New River's perfectly balanced between a lovely hoppy bite and actual full, sticky malts.

I've read something that Victory claims their recipes haven't changed, but about everyone I know agrees that in the last two years Old Horizontal and Storm King have really taken a significant step backward. I've only had Hop Devil a couple of times in the last year or two, but it just didn't have the bounce it used to. It wasn't that it seemed less hoppy or anything but that the malt seemed thinner than it used to.

OH and SK used to be my favorite beers on the planet, but something's been off for the last few years. 2005 SK was at least decent, but the

2004 was positively terrible.

Certainly could, but OD's been pretty successful as a growing regional brewery and I'd like to believe nobody's going to screw with what's proved to be a reasonably good business model. That being said, if they want to ramp up distribution and bring their beer to Minnesota, well, I wouldn't exactly pout about that.

Reply to
Dan Iwerks

The fish and chips is a favorite of mine, but the burgers are down right tasty too. You might look into a keg instad of a dozen growlers (grin). Dominion sells a fair amount of their beer to local restaurants too. Red Hot 'n Blue is currently selling one of their ales and Oak Barrel Stout. A 22 ounce glass of stout and ribs...yum!

Reply to
John S.

it's not an ipa it's a pale ale..and it's called alpha king

Reply to
wolfedennis

"Of course, the American beer drinking public is largely stupid, so they'll likely continue to produce the 90 & 120. "

that makes no sense...the majority of the american beer drinkers are drinking the macro produced beers from bud miller and coors.... the smaller majority of beer drinkers are drinking hand crafted brews and from what i've seen and heard dogfish 90 minute is highly regarded as one of the top Double IPA's...on the list of top ipas i would aslo put alesmith ipa, harpoon ipa, smuttynose finest kind ipa and lagunitas ipa

Reply to
wolfedennis

They certainly *call* it a pale ale. But if it quacks like a duck...

Reply to
Joel

Alpha King is as much an IPA as any. What the brewer calls it is irrelevant

Reply to
VW

And it's delicious. It has this satiny mouthfeel, a lustrous orange/copper color (it is really a visually beautiful beer), and it takes it's time spreading across the palate in shades of hop intensity. If wine drinkers only knew about the spectacular flavor available in great beers like this, they would save a lot of money.

Reply to
Douglas W Hoyt

Ahh, a local.

Yes, Hoptown IPA is quite tasty if you like your IPA's just a tad on the sweet side. I do. Another sweetish IPA along the same lines is Wet Mountain, a very good IPA from a small pizza chain/micro brewery called Il Vicino's. As a bonus, their pizzas are killer. The best I've tried.

formatting link

nb

Reply to
notbob

Joe, the bottled stuff, which is contract brewed, is nowhere near as good as the real deal. If you can get to one of the breweries (CO SPRNGs), do it. The bottled stuff is really inferior. You can buy growlers to go (2L) and they will even fill your 5 gal corny keg for $40 (roughly 4 cases of beer). Wet Mountain. Yum!

formatting link

nb

Reply to
notbob

The first time I tried Racer 5 I was less than impressed. Turns out one of their early releases just didn't get it and a few cases escaped. I tried the newer stuff and it's not bad. But, I'd much rather have my favorite, Drake's IPA from the Drake's Brewing CO in San Leandro CA. This is a very malty and hoppy IPA without being too syrupy and heavy. Not everyone will like the strong malt profile, but the equally strong hops profile balances perfectly and still leaves a clean underwhelmed palate. In fact, I just talked myself into a sixer.

nb

Reply to
notbob

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.