The word pub was not in my posting, Midgehole club is open to members, their guests and CIU affiliates as far as I can see.
There are quite a few clubs in the GBG that say "show this guide or Camra membership to be signed in". Maybe they should be reported to some great authority too!
As for Moyles. Five different beers at reasonable prices, good variety, well kept, 20p off for CAMRA members, friendly staff and customers all a lot more important than the docor.
formatting link
has pretty good recent reviews (one by me admittedly)
Think i'll go back to lurking.