Two recent tastings: 04 du Tertre and 05 Eden Vale pinot

Been absent for far too long after moving from Yale and losing (convenient) Usenet access :-(.

Two recent tasting notes, one bad and one excellent. I'd bought (I think based on a rec here, actually) a few bottles of the 2004 Chateau du Tertre, and after having had them in storage for a while during moves, we were reunited a little while back, so finally opened one: very disappointing, with much oxidation and almost no nose. My guess is a bad bottle, but hope the others are better: I post just to check whether anyone happens to know that this might be in a poor period right now?

The other recent wine to make a big impression came from winestilsoldout.com, which I've had good experience with recently: the

2005 Eden Vale pinot noir. This was silky, rich and almost slightly syrupy, definitely 'big' for a pinot but not over the top, good caramel and woodsmoke. Really very good; I went back out and bought a case, and will look for future releases.
Reply to
Ewan
Loading thread data ...

Good to see you back here, Ewan, and congrats on the tenure track appointment and the NIH grant! Regarding Usenet access, you might want to look into one of the various free newservers that permit posting privileges, such as news.aioe.org, news.motzarella.org, news.x-privat.org and news.mixmin.net. I've given up on my ISP's newsgroup access and just use aioe.org, which has been quite reliable.

Notes on Cellartracker would indicate that you did indeed have a bad bottle. Could it be a storage issue? Or perhaps just a bad cork. Whichever, 'tis a shame.

Mark Lipton

Reply to
Mark Lipton

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.