Mislabeled "white peony"

Apr 02, 2006 11 Replies

I obtained some bagged tea marketed by Triple Leaf Tea, Inc named on the carton as 'White Tea ~ White Peony Tea'. It's price in the supermarket for



20 bags aroused suspicion: only US$3.30. White peony tea is normally the most expensive Chinese variety. Granted that this brand is offerring tea dust, not whole leaf, but so is Republic of Tea (RT) in their Emperor's White Tea bags, which costs considerably more. It is not even found at the Triple Leaf Tea (TLT) web site
formatting link


This tea from TLT is a mixture of dark olive green dust and an estimated 5% beige cottony looking agglomerations. I know that true white peony does have a fine gray-white down on its young buds, but I've never seen beige fiber masses such as this in a teabag before. It certainly does not look a bit like the white peony dust found in the Emperor's White Tea bags.



When 2 of the TLT bags are steeped in 10 oz water @ 180°F for 10 minutes (the way I prefer my green/white teas), the result is an *amber* colored infusion and noticably robust tannin flavor that I'm not accustomed to in other green/white tea brands. It should't be so dark unless it has undergone considerable oxidation/fermenation. Both the appearance and flavor of it seems comparable to that of an Oolong. And I immediately felt almost nauseous after drinking only about half of the serving. Was that pesticides or some sort of additive, which caused my reaction?



I've read that there is a type of white tea that is more specificly named Shou Mei

formatting link
"A fruity furry white tea that is a chaotic mix of tips and upper leaf, it has a stronger flavor than other white teas, similar to Oolong. It is the fourth grade of White tea and is plucked later than Bai Mu Dan (Pai Mu Tan) hence the tea may be darker in color. From Fujian Province and Guanxi Province in China."



However, Pai Mu Tan translates to 'white peony', whereas Shou Mei translates to 'Noble, Long Life Eyebrow'.



I'm also aware that April 1st is quite out-of-season for white peony, so any inventories of it cannot be expected to be fresh. However, it should not be so oxidized/fermented after only 13 months of normal commercial storage that its variety is unrecognizable. So evidently it never was white peony to begin with.


It could be one part BaiMudan to whatever parts of filler so they can make the claim. Or from your description more SowMee than BaiMudan. SowMee is the end of season dark brown leaf. BaiMudan is midseason 50% green leaf/white bud. Yinzhen is the first all bud of the season. The only white tea that is cheap is SowMee. It doesn't make any sense to me to put any white tea in a bag except maybe SowMee which is so cheap the bagging would cost more. The grading just doesn't work that way to make fines/dust. White tea in bags is more marketing than anything else.

Jim

Knack wrote:

Hi,

I happen to know that Triple Leaf does produce a white tea > It could be one part BaiMudan to whatever parts of filler so they can

If any white tea was sold as small grade I could see fines/dust as a by product for teabags. Since it isn't you get what you pay for. I bought some puer tea bags once which was 50% cork. You could believe the claim on the box for multiple infusions because it would never get water logged and sink. I'm not even curious to buy cheap white tea bags in Chinatown. However if I was sure it was midseason 100% White Peony I'd load up.

Jim

ah2323 wrote:

Space Cowboy:

Cork? Really? That is shocking, and--I think--illegal under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (1938). Is there any way to know whether what you are getting is actually tea at all?

Space Cowboy wrote:

I double checked the puer teabag in question. It is a Taiwan brand and either 50% cork or 50% chrysthanthemum flower. It still could be used as a liferaft.

Jim

ah2323 wrote:

Somehow I always pictured you as bigger than that. Or is it a *huge* teabag?

/Lew

It would have to be bigger than huge to keep me afloat. But even a little would probably work as a shark repellent. If the boat leaves without me like in Open Water I want some of this stuff.

Jim

Lewis Per>

It *says* that? Or is this an educated guess?

Space Cowboy wrote:

BTW, I have had bagged Pu erh before. It wasn't as good as even inferior whole leaf, but it did taste *like* Pu Erh, and it didn't display any particular buoyancy. The only tea-like product I've ever had behave that way was a certain well-known brand of Rooibus (sp?).

It was an educated guess when I double checked the teabag. I just checked the box. It says Chrysthanthemum Flower Puerh Tea in Chinese. It is common to drink the two together. Maybe the flower is more buoyant than the tea.

Jim

ah2323 wrote:

Actually, I think I've tried it before, although I don't remember it floating. Not great, but at .79 for a box of 20, could have been much, much worse.

Space Cowboy wrote:

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required