Insanity of the wine industry

Dick, I recently answered a similar question from you. Did you see my answer?

formatting link
snipped-for-privacy@48AEE8.DCC3E%40purdue.edu

It also depends on your being able to view all the header records, of which the NNTP-Posting-Host is but one. To do that in OE, see this link:

formatting link

If you want a more detailed explanation, feel free to contact me by e-mail and we can discuss it at length.

Mark Lipton

Reply to
Mark Lipton
Loading thread data ...

No need for a chemist, the answer is quite simple: grape variety in general, and especially riesling when we talk about Germany.

M.

Reply to
Michael Pronay

thanks. I see what you did and found the header.

Reply to
dick

Vino

I'm not going to quote this last post, as this whole discussion is getting a little hard to follow. I was just trying to clarify Vincent's position.

I certainly never questioned the alcohol levels on any bottle of wine (WA or otherwise). I was merely citing my source of that information, as I have no inside information about the WA wine industry. I have observed that off dry Rieslings from Washington have higher alcohol levels (12%) than the "equivalent" product from Germany, where the wines range, according to labels, from 7.5 to 11%. Again, I accept these figures as correct. By "equivalent", I was attempting to compare off dry Riesling from Washington with those from Germany, and remind (Is that the correct word?) Vincent of the differences that might account for the different acidities. Clearly, the WA and German wines are very different.

Unfortunately, Vincent tends to jump around and become defensive, without trying to zero in on the meat of the matter. I think he is suggesting that concentrated must, either due to the freezing of the grapes or due to botrytis, would not lose acidity as the sugar levels rise, as would a "naturally ripening" grape. This is actually an interesting question.

I'm happy to clarify my points. I just wish Vincent were a little less defensive, so that we get to the correct science, without the back and forth attacks (which, I believe, Vincent has largely precipitated).

Tom Schellberg

Reply to
Xyzsch

Vincent

I may be reading these posts out of order. First, I don't think there would be two different reading for sugar levels if we are talking about botrytized wines. The grapes are already partially dessicated when picked, due to the action of mold. So this seems to explain why many late harvest German wines would have high sugar and high acidity.

But botrytis is not universal in these wines, and the plot thickens. Michael Pronay says it's the grape, but I don't have the chemisty background to support or to refute this

Tom Schellberg

Reply to
Xyzsch

"equivalent", I

are you directing your question to me? if so, i will respond about acidity levels in botrytisized wines/ icewines/ concentrated wine vs. typical dinner wines.

As a grapes mature and rippen,, (i think i said this all before somewhere in this tread) sugar levels increases, ph increases and TA is reduced along with acids becomming limited to primarily tartaric. Lets say a Cabernet grape from California matures something like this:

stage 1: TA2.0 - PH2.4 - Brix12 stage 2: TA .9 - PH3.6 - Brix20 stage 3: TA .5 - PH3.5 - Brix22 stage 4: TA .2 - PH4.3 - Brix27

Figure that about stage 4, the grapes start dehydrating. Another few weeks of hanging, you pretty much have raisins. Of course,, these numbers change according to grape variety and climate. Some here are accusing me of disputing this fact; I am not. However: I am defending the FACT that "As a grape matures and rippen,, sugar levels increases, ph increases and TA is reduced" To the best of my knowledge I have never seen any evidence to the contrary nor has any been presented here.

If a grape is harvested at stage 3 you will end up with relatively stable wine. Ice wines and similiar items are made when these grapes are frozen / then thawed and pressed. Sugar and other compounds thaw before water. As the sugar thaws and drops, it is collected. Sugar concentrtion could start really high (50-76brix). When the water/ice starts thawing the brix goes down. At a certain point the process is stopped and the remaining ice is discarded.

The dehydration of juice can also be done on the vine. Boytrits, in some circumstances, can attack a grape cluster and dehydrate the fruit,, causing a concentration of sugar and other compounds.

Dehydration can also be accomplished by (my favorite) advanced concentration machinery. There are some pretty neat pieces of equipment on the market.

All different degrees of concentration can be accomplished and they vary.

NOw... I am assuming from things I have learned in this thread,, that most German wines are harvested around stage 2 then concentrated, or,,, concentrated than harvested around stage 2, by one of the methods descibed above.

During concentration water is removed therefore Brix and TA increase,, PH will stay about even. So a german wine could end up being .9TA - PH3.6 -

10% alcohol - 2% sugar. This makes a balanced and chemically stable wine (with sterile filtration or potassium sorbate)

ON the other hand,,, If the grapes were left to mature on the vine they will continue to increase in sugar, acididty will be reduced ,and the PH will increase.

I hope this was helpful.

Vincent

Reply to
Vincent Vega

Not sure I understand you correctly.

I explained in my other posts how dehydration is achieved by other methods

hmmm,,, Yes,, different grape varieties mature to different level but I have never heard of a grape that will mature to 35+ brix without becoming a raisin. If there is such a grape, I know people who will pay big money for it. Let me know where I can get some cuttings.

Reply to
Vincent Vega

I think you've set yourself an impossible task, but I wish you the best of luck.

As I've indicated in earlier posts, I clearly have a special place in my heart for Columbia Valley rieslings. This doesn't mean that I can't appreciate (and like) rieslings from Germany, Alsace, the Finger Lakes area, and hell, even some areas of Australia. But I'm tired of hearing CV rieslings being dismissed because "they aren't like German rieslings". They're not intended to be like German rieslings. Whether one likes them or not is beside the point. I just wish people would stop comparing them with standards they were never intended to correspond to.

Right on!

It is. At some point, the physiological processes that occur in ripening (or over-ripening) grapes stop. If, after that, the only thing that happens is removal of water, i.e dehydration, then TA should not decrease, although sugar concentration will increase. My sense is that, with ice wine, these processes have stopped. With botrytis infected grapes, I don't know.

I agree completely.

Vino To reply, add "x" between letters and numbers of e-mail address.

Reply to
Vino

Hey, y'all, there is something singular here. An achievement in teasing out the most reponses I can recall in some interval of live reading and archives on wine. Especially, the most responses in one thread, that promised to be "the last thing I am going to post on this thread," or similar words. (Credit where due!)

"Mike Tommasi" in news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com...

Reply to
Max Hauser

Botrytis makes the skin permeable. This leads to evaporation of volatile components, including water and acidity. But the water evaporation rate being far superior to the rate of aciditiy, acidity content goes up, not down.

M.

Reply to
Michael Pronay

What misconception? What misunderstanding? Sounds like you are filabustering. You did nothing but repeat what I already said. What am I wrong about? Get off your elitist pedistal and stop claiming I dont know what I am talking about when you seem to agree with everything I am saying.

Reply to
Vincent Vega

Salut/Hi Tom S,

le/on Fri, 16 Apr 2004 09:21:39 -0700, tu disais/you said:-

Give it up, Tom, the guy's a contumaceous pillock. By quoting all his drivelling disputatious crap, you merely make it harder for those who've long put him in our killfile to avoid him.

He WILL not read what's written, he WILL not listen to a word anyone says except to bloody argue the whole time. Let it drop, life's TOO damn short.

Don't bother. Even the most patient here (I am not amongst them) has given up.

Reply to
Ian Hoare

Thanks for your reply Vino.

I was not trying to suggest that WA rieslings are better, worse or the same as those from Germany. I was merely suggesting that a given grape grown in different climatic conditions can give much different results re acidity, alcohol content etc. That is really what this dicussion is all about, and why I wanted to emphasise that point in my post.

Tom Schellberg

Reply to
Xyzsch

Sorry to go back so far to a thread that had (mercifully) petered out, but I just read a reply (sent by e-mail; I won't go into why I was so late reading it) to the question I posed about the source of the above data on sulfide concentrations. It is

formatting link

As I read the chart used for the data, it refers to typical sensory thresholds for the listed compounds, NOT typical amounts actually found in wine. The earlier interpretation simply did not make sense to me and probably didn't to others as well.

Vino To reply, add "x" between letters and numbers of e-mail address.

Reply to
Vino

Note also that the figures on the chart are "ppb" (parts per billion), not ppm, as th original poster indicated. That was a major reason for my skepticism.

Vino To reply, add "x" between letters and numbers of e-mail address.

Reply to
Vino

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.