Stella Artois - adverse effects?

Hi all,
I have a number of friends who claim that Stella Artois effects them in an adverse manner. Basically, they reckon they get a lot more drunk on Stella than on the same amount of any other lager/beer of the same alcohol content. Not sure where most of you come from, but Stella has the nickname "wifebeater" here in England, due to it's supposed propensity to incite violence in it's drinkers. Personally, I don't find it effects me any differently to beers of the same strength. Does anyone know if there really is anything about it that would make it more potent than other beers? Or is it, as I suspect, all in their minds?!
Cheers, Dan
Reply to
<a>
>Calling Stella "wifebeater" is more a reflection >on the type of guy who drinks Stella than it is on Stella.
That's exactly what I was going to post Lew. It's a 5% beer, so if you drink 10 pints of it you're going to get drunk, and if you're the sort of person that gets violent when they're drunk...
BTW, I've never heard Stella called 'wifebeater' here - crap, expensive etc. are more common terms. It's marketed as a premium beer, unlike in Belgium where it is an everyday session pilsner.
Best regards, Paul -- Paul Sherwin Consulting
formatting link
Reply to
Paul Sherwin
> BTW, I've never heard Stella called 'wifebeater' here - crap, > expensive etc. are more common terms. It's marketed as a premium beer, > unlike in Belgium where it is an everyday session pilsner.
Well, the name does translate to English as Lone Star.
Cheers,
Steve
Reply to
Steve Moore
wrote in news:40f5bf29$0$6448$cc9e4d1f@news-text.dial.pipex.com: > Hi all, > > I have a number of friends who claim that Stella Artois effects them > in an adverse manner.
I suppose forcing your taste buds to interact with Stella counts as an "adverse manner" in my book. -- ***************************************************************** Dan Iwerks thinks that the beer you're drinking probably sucks. The fundamental problem with Solipsism is it makes me responsible for the fact that you're a complete idiot. *****************************************************************
--
*****************************************************************
Dan Iwerks thinks that the beer you're drinking probably sucks.
 Click to see the full signature
Reply to
Dan Iwerks
> Well, the name does translate to English as Lone Star. > ?? "Stella" translates into "star", in Latin (Stella started life as a Christmas pilsner). "Artois" is a family name, related to a region in North France-Flanders.
Whence the "lone"? Joris
Reply to
Joris Pattyn
> Not sure where most of you come from, but Stella has the nickname > "wifebeater" here in England, due to it's supposed propensity to incite > violence in it's drinkers. Personally, I don't find it effects me any > differently to beers of the same strength.
So, you beat your wife no matter what you drink?
Brian
Reply to
Brian Lundeen
>>Well, the name does translate to English as Lone Star. >> > > ?? > "Stella" translates into "star", in Latin (Stella started life as a > Christmas pilsner). > "Artois" is a family name, related to a region in North France-Flanders. > > Whence the "lone"?
It's a joke. "Lone Star" refers to beer from Texas, legendary home of "Bubba the wife-beater." Bubba gets a little mean and nasty when he's drunk enough Lone Star beer. He's sort of a notorious Texas stereotype. -- dgs
--
dgs
Reply to
dgs
>Hi all, > >I have a number of friends who claim that Stella Artois effects them in an >adverse manner. Basically, they reckon they get a lot more drunk on Stella >than on the same amount of any other lager/beer of the same alcohol content. >Not sure where most of you come from, but Stella has the nickname >"wifebeater" here in England, due to it's supposed propensity to incite >violence in it's drinkers. Personally, I don't find it effects me any >differently to beers of the same strength. Does anyone know if there really >is anything about it that would make it more potent than other beers? Or is >it, as I suspect, all in their minds?!
Here in Australia at least, compared to most other standard beers (local or imported), it has a slightly higher alcohol content. So if you go 1:1 with a mate or whatever, the bloke drinking Stella would be more pissed.
I get really monstrous hangovers after a night on Stella. That, coupled with the fact that is it horrendously expensive here, makes me drink it less than I'd like to.
-- "It's too late to be late again
Reply to
st
> > >Hi all, > > > >I have a number of friends who claim that Stella Artois effects them in an > >adverse manner. Basically, they reckon they get a lot more drunk on Stella > >than on the same amount of any other lager/beer of the same alcohol content. > >Not sure where most of you come from, but Stella has the nickname > >"wifebeater" here in England, due to it's supposed propensity to incite > >violence in it's drinkers. Personally, I don't find it effects me any > >differently to beers of the same strength. Does anyone know if there really > >is anything about it that would make it more potent than other beers? Or is > >it, as I suspect, all in their minds?! > > Here in Australia at least, compared to most other standard beers > (local or imported), it has a slightly higher alcohol content. So if > you go 1:1 with a mate or whatever, the bloke drinking Stella would be > more pissed. > > I get really monstrous hangovers after a night on Stella. That, > coupled with the fact that is it horrendously expensive here, makes me > drink it less than I'd like to.
Yes, this is another claim often made - "I get a worse hangover on Stella than anything else". I can't think of any scientific reason for this so I suspect it's another figment of their imagination. I asked a friend to clarify why Stella effects them more today, the answer was along the lines of "there's some chemical that it's got more of"! I have to agree with all the posts saying it's a load of rubbish, was hoping someone might suprise me with a strange fact or stat though...
Also, I didn't realise how unpopular Stella was - have to admit it's usually my choice of lager in a UK pub (typical draught lager choice is Kronenbourg, Carling, Grolsch, Stella). This is probably why I hear the evils of the drink from other people so much!
Cheers, Dan
Reply to
<a>
> > >Calling Stella "wifebeater" is more a reflection > >on the type of guy who drinks Stella than it is on Stella. > > That's exactly what I was going to post Lew. It's a 5% beer, so if you > drink 10 pints of it you're going to get drunk, and if you're the sort > of person that gets violent when they're drunk... > > BTW, I've never heard Stella called 'wifebeater' here - crap, > expensive etc. are more common terms. It's marketed as a premium beer,
I think "wifebeater" is a northern expression, I say this despite being from Southampton so am probably wrong! Certainly the majority of people in my age group (20's) seem to know the 'affectionate' nickname.
Cheers, Dan
Reply to
<a>
> "st" wrote in message > > I get really monstrous hangovers after a night on Stella. That, > > coupled with the fact that is it horrendously expensive here, makes me > > drink it less than I'd like to. > > Yes, this is another claim often made - "I get a worse hangover on Stella > than anything else". I can't think of any scientific reason for this so I > suspect it's another figment of their imagination. I asked a friend to > clarify why Stella effects them more today, the answer was along the lines > of "there's some chemical that it's got more of"! I have to agree with all > the posts saying it's a load of rubbish, was hoping someone might suprise me > with a strange fact or stat though...
Singha often gets accused of having formaldehyde in it. I did a piece on this (and a few other beer myths) for Beverage Business last year (
formatting link
), and after talking to a brewing chemist I know, and the Boon Rawd folks, pretty much figure that 1)Singha is stronger than most beers in the area at 6%, and 2)Singha is distinctly hoppier than most "international lagers" like Stella, for instance. Strange taste from the hops, walloped by the higher alcohol, well, it can't be the drinker...must be the fooking formaldehyde in the Singha!
Sheesh...
-- Lew Bryson
"As for talking shit in this NG, Lew, you're the undisputed king, and that's no SHITE." -- Bob Skilnik, 1/31/02
www.lewbryson.com
--
Lew Bryson

"As for talking shit in this NG, Lew, you're the undisputed king, and
 Click to see the full signature
Reply to
Lew Bryson
> Yes, this is another claim often made - "I get a worse hangover on Stella > than anything else". I can't think of any scientific reason for this so I > suspect it's another figment of their imagination.
Well, there's nothing I know of in Stella that would cause a worse hangover, but it's not entirely baseless to say "Beer X gives me a worse hangover."
There are some fermentation by-products that affect some people in such a fashion to make their hangovers worse. American Budweiser's yeast is well-known as a prodigious producer of acetaldehyde, which some people react to in such a way that it worsens their hangover (in fact, it's a chemical that naturally occurs in hangovers, so more of it certainly isn't going to help). Certain beers, such as some higher-alcohol Belgian beers (and I'm talking like 8-12 percent), can have higher levels of fusel alcohols that some people may also react poorly too.
But, yes, 9 times out of 10, the "I get a worse hangover" claim holds as much water as the "I get drunker from" claim. And, as I mentioned, to my knowledge Stella does not have unusual levels of either of those chemicals.
-Steve
Reply to
Steve Jackson
>Also, I didn't realise how unpopular Stella was - have to admit it's usually >my choice of lager in a UK pub (typical draught lager choice is Kronenbourg, >Carling, Grolsch, Stella).
A lot of it gets drunk, and I'd agree that it's probably the best draught lager available in a typical UK pub. I used to quite like UK brewed Kronenbourg (nothing to do with the French beers of the same name) but it's become very nondescript over the last few years.
Most people using this NG tend to be interested in specialist beers and won't be too sympathetic towards Interbrew industrial beers whatever they taste like.
Best regards, Paul -- Paul Sherwin Consulting
formatting link
Reply to
Paul Sherwin

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.