Winter Beer Review Part I

I'm slammed with the amount of winter seasonal beers I have in stock right now, a quick trip to my local packy last week yielded a cart full of six-packs which only added to this problem. Thankfully I've been to a couple of holiday parties to go through most of my stock. Hell, I have to start making room for all of the barleywines and imperial stouts that usually come out mid to late winter and soon after that the bocks will be invading. A never ending problem that always ends up being a good problem right? So here is to December

22nd ... the first day of winter.

# Full Moon Winter Ale

formatting link
... /306/39581

So the switched up this years seasonal to an abbey style ale. I do remember a good while back when the Blue Moon brand first came out they did an abbey ale and at the time it was pretty damn good. No problem in the head department, lots of sticky foam with a nearly crystal clear amber color. Watery spice, a hint of peppery alcohol and some husky toasted grain in the aroma. Decent malt character at best, a tad wet and thin with a toasted husk note throughout. Mild hop bitterness is trumped by a mild mannered spicy flare from the yeast. Hint of fruitiness and sweetness in the end like all of the other Blue Moon beers.

People new to good beer might enjoy this, mild and a bit weak in flavor for even a small Belgian. I'll pass next year when this comes around again.

# Our Special Ale 2007 (Anchor Christmas Ale)

formatting link

Damn, I think I forgot about the rest of last years which probably tucked away somewhere deep in my cellar. I'm better off because I still have some 96', 99', 02' & 04'. Lots of mid-sized brown bubbles show an active carbonation and a healthy head. Very dark with brownish garnet hues when put up to the light. Smells of molasses cookies and fruit cake. Very smooth with a spicy character from start to finish. A hint of char and deep caramel malt sweetness in the middle. Quick breath of alcohol and hop bitterness meld with the spicing well. Finishes spicy and a tad dry.

Without a doubt a must have every year, it ages very well for the most part and is a great switch up beer during the winter months.

# Samuel Adams Old Fezziwig Ale

formatting link

Perhaps one of the most talked about beers that Boston Beer Co. has, right after Cranberry Lambic. Another spiced winter warmer but its limited availability drives the demand up IMO. Big towering densely rocky tan head from a hard pour, glowing reddish brown color. You can smell all of the spices used; cinnamon, ginger and orange peel ... mild chocolate malt tone in the back of the nose. Smooth and creamy with a slick full body. Mild burnt tone goes away quickly as the malt sweetness layers the palate and the spicing picks it right back up. Hint of woody hop gets lost with the spicing. Finishes off semi-sweet with a vague chocolate flavor.

Spicing does not go too far, maltiness is big enough to hold the beer together. A solid beer all around and a bit of a conversation beer as well which is good around this time of year.

# Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale (2007)

formatting link

Yeah, here is my hop fix. This one always makes its way into my cart during my hunt for winter seasonals. As for cellaring this beer, its still up for debate. In the past I have had versions that were aged up to 6 years and tasted damn good, others did not last more than a year. Go Figure. Shiny copper penny color, impeccable head retention from the hops. Nose full of hops with each whiff, without a doubt this beer is one of the best examples of a Cascade and Centennial hop aroma combo. Just and smooth as it is crisp with a hardened medium malty body that is quickly surrounded and consumed by the sizeable Chinook hoppiness. Yeah there is malt here, toasted and a touch of caramel. All of that is cleared out from the hops ... love the hop.

2007 is great, I'll be going out to grab a case of this ASAP and I'll save a few to cellar. Yeah, the hops just don't want to leave your palate and that is a good thing.

# Wachusett Winter Ale

formatting link

They made a great choice from killing off their Winter Fest Ale, a spiced winter warmer that was always seemed too spiced and too sweet. Scotch Ale is what they are all about now. Head retention is ok, clarity is fine as well. Malty and a bit of smokiness with a spicy alcohol in the back, clean aroma for the most part. Smooth and crisp medium body with a long drawn out malt character that never reveals all of it sweetness because the smoke flavor masks some of it. Mild hop bitterness. As the smoke faded with alcohol kicks in with a slight spice and lead to a dry toasted malt finish.

Solid all the way, nothing earth shattering ... just flavorful, drinkable and a bit alcoholic which seems to sneak up on you. More than two is enough as the smoke started to get to me.

# Winterhook Winter Ale

formatting link
... /153/27875

One winter seasonal that I have probably seen the most improvement over the years is Winterhook. Its been around since 1985 in one form or another but seems to be on the stable path for several years now. Bright clarity off of the deep copper color brew, awesome looking lacing as it leaves a web like trail down the glass. Malty aroma of toasted grain and caramel, hint of floral and grassy hops as well. The smoothness is certainly there with a small crispness that drops off quick in the medium body. Spicy, herbal and bit time floral hop flavor don a balanced bitterness that lingers far into the drying finish.

High in drinkability, flavorful and a bit complex yet approachable enough to bring to a holiday party. By far its one of my favorites each year.

Reply to
beeradvocates
Loading thread data ...

I hear the cries of winter ales yet to be opened on a daily basis and a small stock of barleywines is starting to mount. I'll have this round and probably on more for winter ales and then I am off to barleywines and perhaps two or three rounds of Extreme Beer Reviews in dedication of our fest. Thanks for all of the reads, I am going to try and stay on top of the seasoanls for the rest of 2008 and if this year flows good enough I'll just keep on going.

# Magic Hat Roxy Rolles

formatting link

Patchy light tan lace crowns the glass, good head retention and clarity to be looked at. Hoppy aroma that lets some malt in, a nose of mandarin oranges, wild flowers, caramel and sweet bread. Very smooth with a medium body. Hop profile flexes with an ample bitterness that throws a woody, herbal and slightly citric flavor. Malt sweetness is there but enough to hold the beer together in body and flavor. Hints of caramel and bread crust. Bit of fruity yeast, mineral and drying herbal hop flavor in the finish.

Hoppy Amber Ale or American Winter Warmer? It has a bit of a northwest flare but still holding on to the Magic Hat traits. Either way, I highly recommend this drinkable ale.

# Ol' Red Cease & Desist

formatting link
... /754/39695

No modest froth here, it comes right to the top of the glass. Ok retention and the clarity is bright. Fruity aroma with a dried biscuit dusting in the nose. Creamy smooth mouth feel, full bodied. Hit of harsh solvent alcohol after each sip, caramel and bready maltiness is there but clouded by the hot alcohol. Hops are minimal. Dry finish with more lingering alcohol heat.

I'm not even sure if age will do this beer any good. Its far from being horrible but it is a chore to sip, it has headache written all over it. A bit too attenuated, hot and fruity for the style.

# Samuel Adams Winter Lager

formatting link

Dark orangey color, good clarity with a quick to froth carbonation and a decent head retention that leaves some lace behind. Wet spicy aroma, a tad malty with some herbal hop in the nose. Creamy medium body with an ample sweetness from the toasted and caramel malt flavors. Spicing and hops keep it balanced with some cininimon and ginger undetones and a spicy herbal hop bitterness. Finishes a bit sweet with warming spices.

I remember when this beer used to be a little bit bigger, badder and ... well better. It used to be closer to 7% abv and with a lot more brawn you would expect from a bock. Todays version is decent, a good pick if you are going to a house or dinner party and don't want to rock the boat.

# Southern Tier Old Man

formatting link
... 3818/14368

Head retention is remarkable with a sizable froth to start and lots of stickage after. Clarity is fine. Deep malty aroma of dark sugars and raisins, hops are not to modest at all with a thick oily nose of tangerine and wild flowers. Creamy slick mouth feel with lots of body, maltiness tries to set in but the bitterness from the hops up roots almost all of the sweetness and holds fast with bitter herb and hard a dried orange peel flavor. This does fade a little and some warming alcohol and caramel sweetness comes through. Finishes bittersweet.

Perhaps some age would be good or not, I like it fresh right now. Bitter and heady. I am sure a little age will dull the hops and bring forth the sweetness in hopes that the alcohol ages just as well. A solid pick for the season.

# St. Peter's Winter Ale

formatting link

The head retention on this beer is pretty amazing, some of the thickest lacing I have seen in a while. There must be a small percent of torrified wheat in this brew. Dark coffee brown color with some ruby highlights. Toffee, some salt water taffy and a ghost like anise in the nose. Very smooth and creamy in a medium body. Sweet caramel and toffee flavors, burnt raisins in the back with a mild char note. Little bit of toasted malt and fruitiness middle to end. Big woody hop flavor has a modest bitterness. Mineral and a tad salty in the drying finish.

Yeah, this is one kick ass winter warmer. Comes in silent and then drops this complex malt bomb on the palate. This one is for the traditionalist.

Reply to
beeradvocates

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.