2005 Claret, a few musings.

Apr 13, 2006 1 Replies

Well they have all had their week on the Gironde and no doubt this weekend the papers will be full of 2005, Jancis in the FT is usually a good read.



Neal Martin has started to write up his notes and I find his writings very succinct and with a very English sense of humour.

formatting link



A member of our wine club who is in the trade, gave us a report at our Tuesday tasting. He was knackered by the sheer scale of the tastings.



A brief précis of findings, but as always DYOR.



The British press were there in droves.



I will not give tasting notes on individual wines as information overload will ensue.



of the appellations. Graves/ pessac-Leognan, a little disappointing, harsh tannins....wait and see? Sauternes/ Barsac, very ripe vintage lacking the complexity of 2001. St Emilion. very good Pomerols, the best the taster had ever tried. Margaux, great wines everywhere. St Julien. Wonderful wines Pauillac Big wines for the long term St Estephe, continues its upwards march.



Some thoughts on marketing and prices.



Stock will be short, a small release only En Primeur, first growths at 250-300 euros a bottle !!!!!! Rumours that the Americans are so determined to get stock they will overbid anyone including the Far East. Rumour that RP has given 15 wines 100 points.



FWIW, I will hold back and wait for the froth to settle. I will buy some but focus on the AC Cru Bourgeois Exceptional, ( The new AC for top rate Cru Bourgeois). Look to Lagune, Chasse, etc.



Do not forget the second wines, I may have a few.



Happy Easter and good drinking


Thanks for the notations. As has been discussed here recently, I'm not sure if I will be picking up many more first-growth Bdx, as I will probably not live long enough to see them mature (same for Vintage Port). That's the problem with getting old.

However, it is nice to hear that the Pauillacs are rating well. When they hit the retail market, maybe I'll splurge and get 1 ea., drink them very young, and regret that I'm not going to be around, when they shape up. :-{

That said, I do have enough from previous vintages to sustain me till my death bed.

Hunt

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required