Almost a month ago, we got a phone call from a friend, inviting us to a dinner involving Wagyu beef. Our friend, who owns two Thai restaurants locally, could obtain high quality Japanese Wagyu beef through some connections he'd made (in the National Restaurant Assn, the other NRA). And so it was that we convened on his house on Sunday to indulge in Wagyu beef. I had agreed to provide the wines for this event. When we got there, we were informed that the beef we would cook was from a steer named Goko, a Satsuma Wagyu of grade A4 (apparently A5 grade is the highest) as attested to by a "birth certificate" that included a nose print.
As a starter, Ake had brought some hamachi sashimi, which we ate with a starter wine:
NV Chandon Brut, which had a coarse mousse but decent acidity and a solid core of appley fruit
Then it was on to the main course. Ake had cubed 5 pounds of the beef and placed 4 large stones in a bonfire. He removed a stone from the fire, placing it on a broiling pan on the table. He then placed a half dozen of the small beef cubes on the hot stone, immediately causing them to sizzle and drip fat. We turned each of the cubes, cooking them on all sides, then sprinkled them with salt and ate. My impression was of beef-flavored foie gras. The flavor was very mild but it was the texture of the beef that one noticed, as it was so tender as to be unlike any other beef I've eaten. With the beef, we had three wines:
1989 Faiveley Corton - Clos de Corton This was the hit of the event, with a lovely nose of earth, smoke and raspberryish fruit. On the palate, it had decent acidity (especially in light on the vintage), a lush mouthfeel and fully resolved tannins. To me, this was a fully mature wine and the best experience I've had with Faiveley to date.1990 Giuseppe Cortese Barbaresco Rabaja Curiously, this wine had next to no nose when opened. This was all about tertiary character: leathery with little fruit left, decent structure but little aromatic complexity. Not totally gone, but this wine was well past peak IMO, though still quite enjoyable.
1995 Montevertine Vino da Tavola Il Sodaccio (1.5 L) Much more appealing than my recent experience with this wine out of 750 mL, this wine was youthful and vibrant, with a nose of pencil lead, leather and cherryish fruit and a rich palate presence with good acidity.All three wines were good with the beef, but the Corton stood out among the three, at least to me.
Mark Lipton