Campden VS Hot Water

We have been making fruit wine for over 40 years. We have always used Campden tabs or metabisulfite. We also utilize fruit we freeze and thaw with boiling water. It seems that using the bisulfite causes the yeast to start very slowly. Seeing that we use boiling water, do we need to use the bisulfite? At what temperature does wild yeast get killed?

We soon are starting 15 gallons of blueberry wine and 15 gallons of raspberry. I'd like to try to get a faster yeast start and thought of eliminating the bisulfite, depending upon the hot water.

Any comments?

Reply to
Andie Z
Loading thread data ...

My own response to this question, since I generally freeze most of my fruits before use, is that I defrost them totally and then treat with crushed and liquidised campdem tablets.

I have not boiled my fruits for over 20 years and do not like the taste of "boiled fruit" wines

Just my own way of doing things but I think you will find it to be the best practice!

Reply to
Pinky

Since the whole point of adding sulphites is to stun or kill unwanted yeasts and bacteria, if you pitch your yeast too soon after adding the sulphite you can delay or even prevent fermentation.

I add my sulphite and then wait until the next day to pitch the yeast (18 to 24 hours), giving the sulphite time to bind.

As far as whether or not to add it at all, your must can pick up yeasts and bacteria from the air--at first it will be protected by the CO2 released in the fermentation but once that slows down it will be susceptible. And adding the sulphite at that point could kill your wanted yeast and stick your fermentation.

Reply to
CJ

You don't say anything about adding wine yeast. Are you depending on natural yeast for your fermentations? If so, there is no point in adding the campden/K metabisulfite. It will only slow the process. However, if you are using wine yeast, make a starter out of some of your juice a day or so ahead of thawing the bulk fruit. The starter will be fermenting fast by the time you add it to your main batch. It should take off immediately.

Bill Frazier Olathe, Kansas USA

Reply to
William Frazier

Hi Andie,

That is an interesting question you've brought up. What I must point out first of all though is that if you simply use the boiling water to thaw the fruit then the temperature of the fruit would be fairly constant at around 0 degrees celsius (32 farenheit) this is due to something called the 'latent heat of fusion.' What this means as it applies here is that unless you continue heating the fruit AFTER it has thawed (i.e. all the ice crystals within the fruit have melted), the temperature of the fruit will not get very high. You need to maintain a temperature in excess of about 50 degrees celsius (~122 F) in order to kill the yeasts - realistically a higher temperature would need to be used (many yeasts can survive for quite a while at relatively high temperatures).

If you are infact heating the fruit to perhaps 80 degrees celsius (176 F) or so, then I would think you could probably get away without using metabisulfite in the initial stage. Sulfur dioxide (as was pointed out above) primarily 'stuns' the wild yeast, hopefully long enough that your wine yeast can get a good head-start. Even though your must is 'unprotected' while it cools (before you add the wine yeast) any invasion of wild yeasts will still be on the backfoot against your more vigorous (and hopefully properly hydrated and prepared) wine yeast.

I hope this is of some use to you, I wish you the very best of luck,

Regards,

Michael

Reply to
MBaker

That's the answer I was looking for. It gives me a basis to work with. If I monitor the temp before I pitch my hydrated and proofed yeast, I can feel comfortable if the temp was high enough. Thanks.

Reply to
Andie Z

I don't like using boiling water. If you want a faster yeast start then make a starter at the same time you add the meta to the must. In face, the must can be cold from the frozen fruit when you add it. Anyway, get the starter going good while the meta sits in the must for 12-24 hours then add the starter. It will go good.

Ray

Reply to
Ray Calvert

You have to get tht fruit to a temp of at least 140 F to kill yeast off.

Just dumping boiled water on frozen fruit will most likely not pasturize it.

Reply to
Droopy

I always make a proofed yeast starter in a quart jar. I make sure it's going very good. Sometimes two days ahead and I always make sure it's working vigorously. And yet, if I use 1 Campden per gallon (6 to 15 gallon batches) it can take two or three days to really start. If we don't use Meta-bisulfite, such as in a batch of bananna wine where we boiled the banannas, the yeast became vigorous in minutes.

Reply to
Andie Z

I'm with Trevor on this one. I see no good reason to boil the fruit. Fresh (or freshly thawed) fruit tastes better than cooked fruit, so why shouldn't it make better wine too?

If you're concerned about wild yeast, just use a large concentration of cultured yeast to overwhelm the wild.

Tom S

Reply to
Tom S

"tastes better" really comes down to preference. I take your point but I don't think it is really reasonable to say that the wine is better if it isn't boiled - sure a lot of the volatile esters and things are lost in the heating process - but at the same time it [the heat] is driving chemical reactions that introduce new/different flavour profiles.

Michael

Reply to
MBaker

Yeah, I understood that - but I still think you should try doing it both ways. I believe your concerns about wild yeast are exaggerated, and that even minimal heating such as you do damages the fruit to some extent. Try tasting flash Pasteurized orange juice against the same stuff that isn't Pasteurized. That's quite analogous.

Tom S

Reply to
Tom S

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.