Desert Island Single Malts

On Sun, 01 Feb 2004 17:04:45 GMT, the alleged Bromo, may have posted the following, to alt.drinks.scotch-whisky:

1) Talisker 10 2) Macallan 18 3) Ardbeg 18 (Cadenhead)

Regards, Rob

-- "Or better yet, use the Jack Daniels `shot and a chaser' glass. An honest admission of the true nature of Tennessee whiskey."

-- Bushido in alt.drinks.scotch-whisky

Mine would be any from the following three distilleries (single malt):

Daluaine Edradour Ardbeg (preferably their new Uighdal [excuse the spelling])

: If you could pick 3 single malts as your only malts, which would they be?

1. Lagavulin (16)
2. Lagavulin (16)
3. Lagavulin (16)

Oh, but seriously:

1. Lagavulin
2. Talisker
3. Laphroig

Justin

I would end up choosing the following, with much teeth-gnashing and wailing...

Springbank-1966 Local Barley

Ardbeg-Lord of the Isles

Longmorn-Signatory 23y Cask Strength 1972

with Talisker 25y Cask Stength coming in a very close fourth...

feroce

Signatory Dailuaine 1985 is the only expression of this whisky that I`ve purchased, so my experience with this dram is limited. I`ve gotta say though- damn, I loved this one. Citrus, citrus, citrus! I notice that Loch Fyne has available a Dailuaine

1980 21 year old from Adelphi as well as a 'Connoisseurs Choice' 27 year old. Has anyone tried these?

Er, oh yes, the other two.

Bruichladdich 15 Glenfarclas 30

Scott Helesic Kingston, Ontario Canada

"The Internet: A vanity press for the deranged." -Erik-Lars Nelson