Should of just burned a $ 20 bill

Taking a moment's reflection, dopey mused: | | Aberlour 10 yr .... toxic s**nk water. Yikes.

Must have gotten a bad bottle, or there is something wrong with your tongue.

I'll let the other 4 folks that sampled it know that it must have been a bad bottle :-)

Paul

"dopey" wrote

Do any of the samplers appreciate Islay whisky, or is this a group of dilettantes hoping to recapture the grandeur of Makers Mark?

Two of the four like Islays. The other two lean toward less intense flavor.

Note to self:

If you post 3 messages, the two that sing the praises of a product will be ignored and the one that expresses distaste for another product will be ridiculed and taken personally.

Cheers

P.

Taking a moment's reflection, J Derby mused: | | Do any of the samplers appreciate Islay whisky, or is this a group of | dilettantes hoping to recapture the grandeur of Makers Mark?

Aberlour is a Speyside malt ...

"mhicaoidh" wrote

I *could* say that I meant to use Islay as an allegory, because it serves as the paragon for connoisseurs...but that would be a lie. I confused Ab10 with Bowmore 10, based in part on the price listed by the OP($20). I'm sure that there's a peaty Freudian element to it, but I haven't figured out what it is, as of yet. Five minutes after I posted, I realized my error. Oh well, is FWP anything like peat ;-P