Tasting notes: Evan Williams, and Johnnie Walker Black Label

A few days ago I was at Total Wine and picked up 2 bottles
of whisky:
- Johnnie Walker Black Label Scotch Whisky, 375ml ($18)
- Evan Williams Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 50ml ($1)
My tasting notes:
Johnnie Walker Black Label: Smell in glass is of rubbing
alcohol, nothing else. Flavor on sipping shows a touch of
toasted oak, a little sweetness, a little malt. Adding a
splash of water tames the alcohol and draws out a slight
hint of peat. Overall impression: bland, undrinkable swill.
My grade: F. Waaaaay over-priced at $18/375ml.
Evan Williams Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Smell in
glass is an over-powering, heady bouquet of flowers and
herbs. On sipping, luscious velvety texture and rich,
strong odors of flowers, herbs, fruit, leather, soap,
women's perfume, and other things I can't begin to
identify. Intoxicating witch's brew. Startling and
off-putting to someone like me who's idea of "whisky"
is Macallan, Glen Morangie, or Laphroaig. But I like it.
Overall impression: Strong, complex, rich, well-balanced.
My grade: B. (And that's from a Bourbon-hater.)
An amazing whiskey! And I only paid $1 for it (albeit
a tiny bottle.) I wish I'd bought 18 bottles of this
instead of spending that $18 on Johnnie Walker Black.
I hope Johnnie Walker Green is a WHOLE lot better than
their Black (which, in my opinion, sux), else I may skip
the Green and go for a single malt in a few weeks.
Reply to
Robbie Hatley

Site Timeline Threads

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.