Fun surprise with mushrooms

Dec 10, 2012 12 Replies

I was debating whether or not to put some mushrooms on my Risotto Milanese last night so I popped couple in my mouth to taste them. Not so good so I opted out ofthe mushroom garnish. I then tried a sip of the Barbera d'Asti that I had opened. I had orignally wanted to go with Dolcetto but didn't have any. I suppose a Valpolicella might have been a little nicer, but the real shock was the absolute horrible vinegar sour etc taste. As per custom I had Beverly try. She said, "Yumm I like it!" end result Barbera so so with Osso Bucco but OMG bad with off over the hill mushrooms!



Joseph Coulter having found my eternal september settings again!


Depending on the mushrooms, you could have made yourself really sick. I'm assuming these were store bought not picked. Many bolletes can have really negative reactions with alcohol in some folks.

Very interesting, Joseph. That's the magic of food/wine pairing for you ;-) Did you go back to the risotto? How did the wine taste with it senza funghi?

Mark Lipton

Really? I know that Boletus satanus will make you very sick, and even more so when combined with alcohol. and there are a small handful that are simply inedible. I can't think of another one that's particularly reactive with alcohol.

Certainly are a lot of other somewhat poisonous mushrooms where the effects are worsened by alcohol, though.

Some people have problems with alcohol and all bolettes.

As far as I know, B. satanas is (mildly) poisonous, regardless of alcohol pairing

formatting link
and hardly edible, due to its bitter taste and putrid smell (except maybe in very young specimens) Now, (some) ink caps are horses of quite a different color
formatting link
No idea if you have them there, the shaggy one is a treat

The risotto was marvelous (I make a damn fine risotto if I say so myself) The mushrooms were garden variety store bought buttons that were over the hill a little bitter but the mix with the wine was off the wall bad.

We get shaggy manes every fall. They don't last long and must be cooked quickly. I make shaggy mane rellenos out of them.

Interesting, I didn't know that, thanks.

I know someone who ate it intentionally and got quite sick. Luckily it's rare and very easy to identify.

Yes, they often grow on the front lawn, although we didn't get any this year (terrible year for cepes also).

We got almost no bolettes this year. Last year I picked 6 pounds in an hour. This year not quite a pound and it took 3 hours to find them.

Heh, must be a global phenomenon. We had the same couple to the farm for Thanksgiving this year as last, they were convinced they'd be bringing a huge harvest back to Paris with them; in reality, nothing.

What Boletus varieties do you find out there?

We get king and white varieties and last year great. This year meh.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required