SF/Bay Area wine store for Gruner Veltliner?

Sep 11, 2005 18 Replies

I'll be in San Francisco on Saturday for what's essentially a fundraiser picnic at Golden Gate Park. I have an oenophile friend I'll be visiting in October with a wine celler of more than a thousand bottles, maybe a couple of thousand. Needless to say, my gifts of wine are generally nothing special. I bought "Oldman's Guide to Outsmarting Wine" (bfson's positive review was right on the mark) and one wine he recommends for wine snobs, er, oenphiles, is Gruner Veltliner. Any suggestions for a wine store open late Saturday where I could get a bottle, either in San Francisco or reasonably close to Interstate 80? Any recommendations for which ones to get? To get it locally, I'd have to special order it. I'd just as soon buy it myself, especially if I get a better choice of wines.


Don't know their stocks, but K&L SF should have some. We had some very nice ones from the list of a restaurant, just around the corner (name eludes me at this instance), and the sommelier stated that he works closely with the folk at K&L. If I can recall, or track down that restaurant, I'll do so, as it was very, very good - just S of the freeway, near China Basin. Dang, I hate getting old!!!!!! :-(

Hunt

Thanks for both the recommendations for the Jug Shop and K&L. Both have it, but the Jug Shop is open later at night. My picnic won't be over before K&L closes. If it's through K&L, it will be mail order. Any of these that are especially good or that should be avoided?

2003 Alzinger Grüner Veltliner Weingärten Smaragd

2003 Bründlmayer Grüner Veltliner Alte Reben

2003 Bründlmayer Grüner Veltliner "Kamptaler Terrassen"

2003 Buchegger Grüner Veltliner Pfarrweingarten

2003 Cantina Valle Isarco "Aristos" Veltliner

2004 Hiedler Grüner Veltliner Löss

2003 Hiedler Grüner Veltliner "Maximum"

2003 Hirsch Grüner Veltliner "Heiligenstein"

2002 Hirsch Grüner Veltliner Lamm "September"

2002 Leithner Grüner Veltliner "Privat"

2002 Malat Grüner Veltliner Dreigärten

2003 Mantlerhof Grüner Veltliner Spiegel

2003 Türk Grüner Veltliner "Vom Urgentein"

2002 Weingut Pfaffl Grüner Veltliner "Goldjoch"

2004 Weingut Pfaffl Gruner Veltliner Weinviertal DAC

2002 Weingut Schmelz Gruner Veltliner 'Steinwand' Federspiel

If Michael Pronay or E. Winemonger should read this, they can give you far better advice than I; however, the producers I can recommend are Bründlmayer, Hirsch, Hiedler, Mantlerhof and Pfaffl. There are some very good wines on your list, but there are also multiple vintages. '03 was a particularly hot year that produced bigger wines that are less typical. I'd probably go for '02 Hirsch Lamm "September" and the '03 Bründlmayer Alte Reben, but more knowledgeable posters might be able to give better advice.

Mark Lipton

Alzinger's basic Smaragd, but also very good. Not tasted.

Not tasted. Should be good.

Basic bottling.

Fine. Rated 90 last year.

;-) This one's not Austrian, but Italian. Interesting, if only for contrast. Nowhere near the top Austrians.

Basic quaffing stuff from a cooler year. Crisp and spritzy.

Superb. Rated 91 last year.

Long-lived. Rated 89 last year.

Fine, rated 89.

Beautifully full and rounded, 91.

Basic bottling, not tasted.

Very fine, 90.

Second rank producer, serious, 88.

Super, 91.

Not tasted, but usually good.

Probably with a plastic stopper and too old. Not tasted.

HTH a little,

M.

K & L is great. You should also check out Vino Venue. There you can taste many many many wines by the glass (using a smart card! It's quite an experience). And as luck would have it, they are pouring some Winemonger imported Austrian wines, including Gruner Veltliner. They're open until 10PM on Saturdays, as they are also a wine bar as well as a shop. Here's their info:

formatting link

Michael covered your list well, but I would give a second "shout out" for the Alzinger, Heidler and Mantlerhof.

e.

formatting link
(for more info on those wines, if you like)

[SNIP]

Sorry that it took so long, but I've been a bit busy with the business of New Orleans & MS.

Here is the restaurant, near K&L SF. Bacar Restaurant & Wine Salon, 448 Brannan St (between 3rd & 4th), SF, CA, USA. The night that we were there, they had about five - six GV's on their list. Seems that we did three, plus a Gregory Graham Viognier. I recommend the food, and you might get to "taste before you buy" some of the GV's on your list.

Regardless, it also sounds like you have gotten some good rec's on GV's with comments by the experts, plus have found a retailer, who can meet your time frame. I've Saved_As the comments, for my next GV shopping spree!

Don't forget to give the group TN's from all of your purposes - or better yet, invite us ALL over to taste them with you. :-)

Good shopping, Hunt

Well, thank you to Mr. Pronay and Mr. Lipton for their recommendations as well as Mr. Hunt for his suggestion for a restaurant. I'll check that out when I have more time. The thing that was most interesting is that some of the more modestly priced GruVe were the ones that Pronay rated 91. I started out seeking a bottle of unusual wine for a gift and ended up dropping a few bills on a whole case of wine I ordered from K&L in San Francisco. I suppose that's a story that many in this newsgroup could tell. Here's what I got:

1 2002 Benton Lane Oregon Pinot Noir (Was $16) @ 12.99 1 2003 Cantina Valle Isarco "Aristos" Veltliner @ 17.99 1 Contadi Castaldi Brut Zero (Was $25.99) @ 9.99 1 2000 Cuvaison Napa Valley Merlot (Originally $30) @ 10.99 3 2002 Leithner Grüner Veltliner "Privat" @ 14.99 1 2001 Olivet Lane Russian River Pinot Noir @ 19.99 3 2000 Sanford 'Sanford & Benedict' Santa Rita Pinot Noir (Was $35 Elsewhere) @ 24.99 1 1999 Vinattieri Ticinesi Merlot "Roncaia" SWISS TICINO (Was 27.99) @ 7.99

I bought one Privat as a gift and two for me. I bought the Italian GruVe as a gift. Also, I'm going to a housewarming in a few weeks so I needed a sparkling wine for that. We'll see how the Italians do it. My question to the other group members would be about the Swiss Merlot. Is it enough of a novelty that an oenophile might be interested in it that I can give it to him as a gift? Or is just another ordinary bottle of wine? Here's what K&L had on it's Web site:

88 points Wine Spectator: "Seductive. Ripe yet elegant, this full-bodied wine offers red fruit flavors, some dried herbs and smoke character, sweet tannins and a harmonious, smooth and long finish. Drink now through 2010." I'm not much of a merlot drinker, but the Cuvaison looks interesting to try. K&L describes the Olivet Lane pinot as a staff favorite. I thought I'd also try the Oregon pinot for $13. The 2000 Sanford "Sanford & Benedict" is a little bit of a gamble. I brought the 2002 Sanford Santa Rita Hills and sat down Sunday night to have it with roast chicken. They talk about pinot noir being a fickle grape and this vintage proved it. There were some berry flavors, but nothing distinctive. The flavors teased me with a finish, but then it disappears. I let it breathe for 90 minutes and all that did was make an awkward oakiness more prominent. I don't know if it will improve with age. I'm not buying another to try it. This vintage is clearly a notch or two below Siduri and Sea Smoke. It wouldn't have been a bad $10 bottle of wine, but it's not worth $26. I would have much rather tried another Siduri. It's not clear to me if the three new bottles come from the same vineyard as the 2002, but I"m guessing based on the price that it's supposed to be a better quality of wine.

^^ Hiedler

100% ack.

M.

M- I could swear you were a grammar teacher in a former life! ;)

-e. "typo" winemonger

Take a look:

or, shorter:

SCNR ;-)

M.

Not in my former life, but my 5-year job as an assistent professor at Vienna University Law School included intense proof-reading. And I still do it with one of the two magazines I write for.

M.

My husband attended there for a year. Perhaps you have corrected him as well....! e.

Could very well be possible. From 1976 to 1982 I was part of the team that corrected the written exam "Einführung in die Grundbegriffe des Staates und des Rechtes", the first exam alle beginners had to take, two months after the start of their studies.

M.

A small world indeed.

By the way, I sent you a private email- let me know if you did not receive it. e.

Got it, but still not sure about what to reply.

M.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required