TN: Champagne, Val d'Aosta, Anderson Valley, Santa Ynez

Aug 27, 2013 3 Replies

Was supposed to hang with some friends Friday, but host was sick, so I stop ped by market for some fish. With swordfish, broccoli,& grilled corn, the 2008 Les Cretes “Cuvee Bois” Chardonnay. I liked this more on a previo us try- the oak seemed less integrated with a bit more bottle age. Good aci ds, full bodied, but despite the acids some buttery notes, and an overlay o f vanillla B-



With roast chicken, squash, caprese, & green salad, the 2009 Copain “tou s Ensemble” Pinot Noir (Anderson Valley). I found this rather disappointi ng at first- some interesting red fruit and smoke, but thin and disjointed, I actually switched to leftover rose for the meal. But I liked much better after a couple hours of air (and it showed fine on day 2 as well). Light t o medium body but with ample red fruits, mineral, smoke notes. B+/B



On a gorgeous Sunday, I had Ahi steak, green beans with tomatoes, and lefto ver squash, with the 2012 Stolpman Rose (Santa Ynez) Crisp, fresh, lighter styled, I’d buy again. B/B+ Monday Betsy was finally home for good after a peripatetic summer, she sai d she would take care of dinner. I was a bit perplexed by the ham and arugu la canapes, sushi, and baby bok choy combination (turned out she was teasin g me about a dream I had reported- and since forgotten). I opened the NV Pa ul Clouet Grand Cru Brut Champagne to celebrate her return. Big, toasty, a touch oxidative, this is not really my preferred style of Champagne, sure o thers would like more. . B-


Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a pa rty where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivi ty, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.


opped by market for some fish. With swordfish, broccoli,& grilled corn, t he 2008 Les Cretes “Cuvee Bois” Chardonnay. I liked this more on a prev ious try- the oak seemed less integrated with a bit more bottle age. Good a cids, full bodied, but despite the acids some buttery notes, and an overlay of vanillla B-

ous Ensemble” Pinot Noir (Anderson Valley). I found this rather disappoin ting at first- some interesting red fruit and smoke, but thin and disjointe d, I actually switched to leftover rose for the meal. But I liked much bett er after a couple hours of air (and it showed fine on day 2 as well). Light to medium body but with ample red fruits, mineral, smoke notes. B+/B

tover squash, with the 2012 Stolpman Rose (Santa Ynez) Crisp, fresh, light er styled, I’d buy again. B/B+

aid she would take care of dinner. I was a bit perplexed by the ham and aru gula canapes, sushi, and baby bok choy combination (turned out she was teas ing me about a dream I had reported- and since forgotten). I opened the NV Paul Clouet Grand Cru Brut Champagne to celebrate her return. Big, toasty, a touch oxidative, this is not really my preferred style of Champagne, sure others would like more. . B-

e, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objecti vity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.

I guess I never really warmed up to Copain wines. I found them often to be thin and disjointed with a bit too much candy apple and cola for my tastes .

Interesting, Bill. I have limited experience with them, having only had the '06 Tous Ensemble PN, but it was lovely.

Mark Lipton

I think it's just me. I visited Copain a couple times and have the wine in the cellar although I have no 2006....presesntly I have a few 2009 and 2010's. By comparison I prefer Failla, Roar, Loring, Talbott to the Copain.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required