TN: Easter- Bdx, Tavel, MSR, Champagne

Mar 24, 2008 9 Replies

Our plan for Easter was to visit Betsy's sister's open house, then return home to work on dinner for friends. However, Betsy was feeling wiped when she got in Saturday night, and by Sunday AM she had a terrible cold. We debated canceling dinner party, but decided she would rest, and I'd be in charge of cooking.



I did drop by sister-in-law's to drop our contributions. While there, I sampled some wines. One red was pretty awful, but I can' t remember name, other wines were better:


2000 Bel Air (Haut Medoc) Softer Bordeaux, ripe blackcurrant fruit and a little lead pencil. Fairly giving (not sure how long before this had been opened), light tannins, pleasant if not especially long Bordeaux.B


2005 Renaud Macon-Villages Plenty of fruit, ripe and round. Seemed to have a very light oxidative note. Went back to bottle to see if I had noted vintage wrong, the ripeness made me think 2003, and it seemed overmature for an '05. But it indeed it was an '05. Pleasant enough Chardonnay, but drink up. B-


2005 Carl Loewen "Leiwener Klostergarten" Riesling Kabinett Crisp apple fruit with a definite overlay of lime, nicely off-dry, sweetness totally balanced by acidity. Good length for a $13 wine, a little hint of slate and petrol. I like this a lot for price. B+/A-

Before I left the party, Betsy called to say Alexandre was sick and their family wouldn't be joining us for dinner. Handily, there were other friends at party that were happy to be invited.



As folks arrived, they were greeted by the Basset, some hummus that Betsy had rallied to prepare, and the 1998 Charles Ellner "Cuvee Prestige" Champagne. Rather full-bodied Champagne, hint of yeast over big apple fruit, some earthy notes. B+   As Betsy and I have divergent views on what meat most represents Easter, we had both ham (orange marmalade/mustard glaze) and lamb (garlic, rosemary, and thyme). We also had roasted root veggies and a broccoli salad. A rose for the ham, 2 Bordeaux for the lamb:


2005 Domaine de Longval Tavel  Strawberries and cherries, bright, a touch of herbs. Not a lot of complexity, but a pleasant wine that handles the sweetness of the glaze well. B


1986 Ch. Meyney (St Estephe) Still a bit tannic when first decanted. As fruit blossoms tannin seems less evident, but this is no delicate claret. Good cassis and black plum fruit, some cedar shavings and tobacco. 22 and going strong. I'd call this mature, but in no danger of fading. Develops a nice little herbal edge with time, I enjoy the dregs while doing dishes. A-/B+


2003 Lilian Ladouys (St Estephe) Red plums and raspberries, noticable but ripe tannins, a bit of damp earth. Better with rarer parts of lamb than without food. Good for under $20 Bordeaux. B

Since I had thought Alex was coming (only person in Dobbs Ferry who loves cheese more  than I), had a rather big cheese spread- Roaring



40s, Camembert, St Nectaire, Torta del Cesar, and a Swiss cheese the guy at Fairway offered as they were out of Hoch Ybrig). We kept with reds, plus a 375 of the1999 La Rame (Ste Croix du Mont). Pineapple and apricot fruit with a little candied orange peel, sweet with some botrytis notes. Others are very enthused about this, I find ok for level, but rather simple despite the noble rot notes. B-   Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.

Thanks for the tasting notes as always Dale. Being Jewish, I always wondered why ham was traditional for Easter since lamb would have been the Paschal dish to serve at a seder (Last Supper). Kind of reminds me of bunnies and eggs. Understand the eggs but bunnies sure don't lay them. Then I always wondered why the egg was present on the seder plate other than some right of spring.

Lawrence, Egg represents life, a new life for the Hebrews leaving Egypt.

The Bunny represents promiscuity... :-)

Yes, I lobbied for lamb because I think of it as a sign of spring and it's a better red match.

Didn't have any idea where ham ttradition started,so did a little googling. Various theories: Ham was considered good luck in certain pagan societies, and was used to celebrate equinox. If picks were slaughtered at beginning of winter as feed ran out, hams reached the perfect point of curing in spring Ham was chosen to differentiate from non-Christian religions that ban it (Judaism and Islam). This seems least likely.

This is very likely....even in the days of the Spanish Inquisisition they used pork fat in a dessert after services, if you did not eat they assumed you were Jewish or Moor and you were slaughtered.

Seems very likely that this was done.

Religion has a way of being very divisive deliberatly in many cases.

Well, it may not have been completely unlikely. The reason the custom of passing a plate of charcuterie developed in Spain was due to the inquisition. Passing a plate of pork products would differentiate a Jew from a non-Jew as the assumed the Jew would not take them.

When I was in Spain, the old city of Palma-Mallorica, there is an old church, previously a Mosque.

They slaughtered Jews and Moslems alike if they did not eat a dessert that was known to be made with Pork Fat.

The Pope to create a more homogenius society that was Catholic made it illegal for Jews and Moslems to live in Spain. So what they did was force conversion. But if you practiced your faith at home, then you were not true to the church. The Pork Fat dessert was how they separated the jew/moslems that they felt were not really Catholic to ethnically cleanse their society as they wanted it.

Larry, I didn't mean it was unlikely as a motive, I'm well aware of the the deep-seated anti-Semitism that Christianity has promoted at various times. I just think that a tradition like this probably was more likely a holdover from pagan rituals (just like Christmas trees, mistletoe, etc). The average medieval Christian didn't fear contact with Jews, because Jews tended to be concentrated in ghettos or rare. The reason that the Spanish clergy and monarchy became so paranoid that they expelled and persecuted the Jews was that in the Moorish period Jews had become somewhat integrated within the society. I don't think it would have occurred to the average Northern European (where tradition started) that a Jew might try to pass himself off as a Christian.

This is part of my family history so I am very familiar with it. My family was at one time from Toledo Spain and became false catholics during the inquisition. They actually moved to Mexico as catholics and remained so until the first Mexican revolution when it then apparently became OK to be Jewish again. They had a family story of the passing of charcuterie as kind of family legend that my grandmother even related to me. Since the Jews were part of the moorish expansion into Spain and elsewhere in Europe, I think this was the origin of at least some of the hatred.

In what way were jew part of the moorish expansion into Spain? I have never heard of that and my family, similar to your was effected.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required