TN Finger Lakes, California, Emilia-Romagna

Sunday Betsy played matinee, I was in charge of dinner. We had some franks and smoked turkey/garlic sausage that had not been used at our Labor Day party. So I made cole slaw, thawed chili, and opened a can of baked beans. Grilled the meat and some endive. Chili/slaw dogs are a childhood memory for me. Wine was from the Finger Lakes, the 2006 Dr. Konstantin Frank Dry Riesling. Despite its name, I thought I detected a little residual sugar, this was just a touch off-dry. Crisp fall apples, some slatey minerality, this might pass unnoticed in a lineup of drier MSR Kabinetts. Gets a little citrus/grapefruit note with time. Maybe a bit short. B

Monday I was in a meeting when Betsy needed a cup of dry white wine, she made her way to cellar and as our agreement took from the "drink now and not too expensive rack." When I got home I tasted a glass of the 2005 Stone Cellars by Beringer Chardonnay. This was a wine brought and abandoned at Labor Day party. I wish it had been abandoned somewhere else. I knew this was a rather industrial product, with I think a generic California designation, but I really tried to keep an open mind (and I think I had a drinkable Stone Cellar red once). But this was ghastly. Canned pears overlaid with microwave popcorn butter, with noticable sugar and oak. Nothing is integrated, no backbone, no character. I wish I could say short finish, but a weird chemical note held on. C-

Luckily it didn't seem to spoil the dish, a Bolognese sauce from a Biba C. cookbook. Betsy served it over pappadelle with a fig/chevre salad and some broccoli rabe. A Bologna recipe, might as well try an Emilia-Romanga wine, the NV (as far as I could tell) Cleto Chiarli "Pruno Nero" Lambrusco Grasparossa di Castelvestro. Bright dark purple color, light bubbbles, Betsy looked and said "what is this?" Light tannins, good acidity. Floral nose, flavors of homemade blackberry jam. Usually the word jam is probably a pejorative for me, but not in this case. That lovely deep concentrated flavor, but as noted there is good acidity. Lightly sweet on palate, though sweetness doesn't seem to carry over to finish. This would be lovely with charcuterie on a picnic, but does pretty well with the Bolognese sauce (with is much more about mirepoix and meat- in this case a pork/veal mix) and the sweetness lets it tango with the figs in the salad. Fun wine for $12. B+

Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency

Reply to
DaleW
Loading thread data ...

Just a quick question. Have you had a Beringer wine in the last 10 years that you liked? I have had a miserable experience with TCA tainted wines, one badly Bret wine and just plain poor winemaking and I used to love Beringer wines in the '80's. Maybe it was just the big hair.

Reply to
Lawrence Leichtman

LOL!!! I've gotta find me some of this wine, Dale. It sounds positively, delightful. :P I've always had a soft spot in my heart for seriously negative wine reviews: they're almost always funnier than any positive review. The problem with most critical wine publications now is that they don't have room for the negative stuff. More's the pity.

Mark Lipton

Reply to
Mark Lipton

I liked a Beringer Knights Valley CS, I think either 2001 or 2002 (can't find note). That was my go-to US wine in early 90s, but prices went way up and quality dropped. This seemed to be similar to old ones, and prices seem to have been stable as other wines shot up. I might consider buying one at a restaurant.

I also own one bottle of the 2002 Sbragia Reserve Chard. Definitely in big over the top style like Newton Unfiltered, not my usual style, but every once in a while......

This one was shocking in how bad it was. Beringer should remove their name from the label, really a reputation-hurter.

Reply to
DaleW

It's actually kind of fun writing the negative stuff. However, the tasting to get there isn't. Rare wine (excluding ones with cork taint or other screaming winemaking faults) that I couldn't even finish my usual 2 oz sample pour. I think Betsy sniffed and decided not to drink.

Reply to
DaleW

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.