TN: Good week of moderately priced wines

Apr 19, 2013 9 Replies

A very good week of wine, with none truly expensive. I recently picked up orders from Chambers St, Wine Cellarage, and Grapes, and was happy with results.



With grilled shell steaks, sauteed mushrooms, potatoes, & salad, the 2011 Vissoux/Chermette "Poncie" Fleurie. Really showing well, black raspberries and mocha, tangy acids, light supple tannins, this could age but I really enjoy this night. B++



Thursday was angel hair pasta with mussels and zucchini, cooking wine was the



2011 Bella Vita Pinot Grigio (Veneto). Clean, crisp, citrusy, what more could you want in $8 PG? B-

But with dinner we actually drank the 2009 Pascal Cotat "Les Monts Damnes" Sancerre. A bit much for the food, but a very good wine. Ripe almost tropical fruit at first, though it seems more citrusy with time. Balanced acids, good length, very good if not great by Cotat standards. B+



There was a cooking wine the following night too, the 2011 Iche "Les Heretiques" - recipe needed 3 cups, and I didn't take notes of the remaining



1+ ounce, but it was as usual a satisfyingly real wine.

Dinner was coq au vin, carrot and zucchini saute, & salad w/avocado,. with:



2009 Drouhin " Clos des Godeaux" Savigny-les-Beaune Midweight, elegant yet with firm tannin and fruit, black cherry and smoke, classy for a village wine. B++

With sockeye with herbs, quinoa, asparagus:



2008 Clemens Busch Pundericher Marienburg Grosses Gewaches OK, this could make a GG believer out of me. White pit fruits, ginger, flowers, with an acidic backbone and minerally finish. Very long. Delicious. A-

With pork tenderloin roasted with a kind of ratatouille-ish assortment of vegetables:



2012 Les Baux Gourgonnier Rose Good value, classic Provencal rose flavors, good food wine. B

With toor dal, okra, & salad



2010 Clemens Busch Pundericher Marienburg Riesling Kabinett Clean, fresh, tasty Kabinett but without the excitement of its GG brother (of course, considerably cheaper!). B

With stirfried beef with Sichuan pepper & salt, a combination of asparagus, squash & snowpeas in a soy dressing, and brown rice:



2006 Peybonhomme les Tours (1er Cotes du Blaye) OK, this isn't going to be a good ringer in a Pomerol tasting. But very nice for what it is- a rather oldfashioned/classic minor Bordeaux, with plums, tobacco, and cedar. Drinking well. B/B-

With "oven-fried" catfish, quinoa, and leftover dal:



2011 Villalin Quincy There was a period where I drank a fair amount of Quincy (mostly Mardon,but others too) but I don't think I've had one in a few years.I should! This was quite delightful- Granny Smith and gooseberry, a little freshly mowed grass, good acids, good finish. Lighter than a good Sancerre, but thats what I expect from Quincy. B/B+

With salmon with radish leaf pesto, green beans, brown rice, watercress:



2011 Foillard "Cotes du Py" Morgon Fresh, silky, all red berries and earth. There's a bit of tannin, good acids, nice length, this seems a bit tight but very nice wine underneath. B+ (with potential)


Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.


Dale-I don't know if you're seeing the Domaine de Montille wines (especially the reds) in NYC but I recently found a stash of the

2009's and at $30 or less they are exceptional values from Burgundy. I posted a note yesterday on the 2009 Beaune 1er Les Sizies that was really tasty at $30...alas the post seems to be lost in cyberspace.
2009's and at $30 or less they are exceptional values from Burgundy. I posted a note yesterday on the 2009 Beaune 1er Les Sizies that was really tasty at $30...alas the post seems to be lost in cyberspace.

---------------------------------- I recently opened an '05 Les Sizies from Pascal Prunier-Bonheur and wished I'd bought more than 3. It was $40 so not quite the bargain you found. I will be cycling around that area next month. Graham

So what are you recommending as an everyday table wine for around $5?

You would be hard pressed to find any wine these days at $5 a bottle.

Well, there is always 3 buck chuck.

It's about $7 in Ohio these days.

at that price point you can get some decent malbec at Costco under the Kirkland label ($6.99 at the Jacksonville FL store)

And now Chuck inflation. Still crap wines.

Is that a Trader Joe's outlet? The Chuck Shaw Chardonnay seems to always be drinkable, but nothing you look forward to. I've given up on the Chuck Shaw reds. If Chuck sells for $7 in Ohio, someone is making a hell of a mark-up. In the Bay Area TJ's it sells for $2.50. I usually have wine with dinner, but even half a bottle/dinner/person gets expensive. I guess if you want to drink cheap, but good, you need to live in France, Germany, Spain, or Italy. The wines I like have gotten crazy expensive, so I drink my $6 Ch. du Buisson, Bordeaux, or Ferme Julian ros at $5, or a TJ chardonnay at $10. Sadly, I started with Leoville las Cases at $16 in the 70s.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required