TN: quasi Superbowl wines- Burgs, Rhone, CA

Feb 07, 2011 3 Replies

A few weeks ago Betsy arranged a dinner for last night with friends we hadn't seen in a while, not realizing it was Super Bowl Sunday. We put football aside and had a good meal (and then I watched 2nd half). In honor of the game she made roasted tomatillo guacamole, and main course was coq au vin blanc, served with egg noodles and kale; dessert was some kind of cookie with Bourbon banana thing (I don't eat dessert).



Cooking wine was the 2007 St. Francis Chardonnay. Pears, toast, butter, very fat. Not my style. C+



a few wines with dinner:


2009 Paul Pernot Bourgogne Blanc This along with Matrot are my perennial Bourgogne buys, but I found the Matrot '09 slightly disappointing. But not Pernot- this is textbook stuff, a basic Bourgogne that could easily pass for Puligny. Fresh acidic backbone, clean crisp Bosc pear fruit with a little note of butterscotch, delicious. B+


2007 Brunel "Sabrine" Cotes du Rhone Villages  Powerful, ripe red fruit, low acidity, could pass for a ripe vintage CdP, not much in the way of oak notes, popular at table, a little too Grenache-y for me. B-


1999 Monthelie-Douhairet "Les Chanlins" Pommard 1er Cru I was worried this might be shut down, but while a bit tight at uncorking it opens nicely, and continues to flesh out throughout night. There's a meaty note that seems Pommardic, but overall this seems more delicate/elegant than powerful, more Volnay than Pommard. That said, it's a lovely midweight, with red and black cherry fruit, earth, smoke, a little espresso note. Fresh acidity, just a hint of tannin, good length. A pleasant surprise. B+/A- Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.

Our Super Bowl party was Barbecue Brisket from Rudy's of Albuquerque and 3 different Orin Swift wines, 2007 Prisoner, Abstract, and Machete. Seemed to go great with barbecue and each one was huge and juicy. B+ on Abstract, B on Machete, A- on Prisoner.

Good QPR in the Abstract..a little weird and not at all like anything I've ever had from the Rhone (as it's marketed) but not a bad bottle for the price. The 2009 Prisoner is by far my favorite. It's toned down about a half step making it a bit more food friendly. BTW, did you mean 2009 on the Abstract and Machete. I think 2009 is the first vintage of these wines.

Sorry, looking at the bottles, they are 2009 on the Abstract and Machete.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required