TN: Xmas wines- PH Rare, Mugnier, Bdx, Sancerre, Goodfellow, more

Dec 28, 2020 0 Replies

A regift from someone who doesn?t drink, the 2015 Real Companhia Velha Evel (Douro) isn?t actually evil, but it?s not good either. A white blend of indigneous grapes, it?s quite musky, moderate acids, and a clipped finish. But worked for cooking wine. C+



Wednesday an assortment of takeout Thai : NV Jacquart ?Mosaïque? Brut Champagne This was fruity to the point of sweet, overdosaged for my tastes, inexpensive Champagne but I can find cheap Cava I like better. C+/B-


2019 Goodfellow Whistling Ridge Blanc A edelzicker-ish blend, a very pleasant surprise. Good acids, low alcohol, bright and minerally. Quite the value. B+/B

No wine Christmas Eve as we went out on the streets (getting back just before a big storm really blew in), but just the two of us Christmas Day (dinner was veal piccata and spinach)


2001 Mugnier Chambolle-Musigny- we were having veal piccata, but I needed a red for Christmas, and there was a thread on another site called "Chambolle with veal piccata." In a good place, perfumed and elegant. Balanced, bright, and earthy. A_ (Best part was label was terrible (was on bottom row on concrete in my passive cellar), so didn't need to think about what this goes for in current insane market.)

I actually opened a second bottle, 2018 Thomas-Labaille Monts Dames Cuvee Buster Sancerre, much better match with the veal.Big-boned style of Sancerre, plenty of acid and flint, long. B+/A-



Saturday was lamb rib chops with broccoli rabe, and the 1998 Ch. Sociando-Mallet. Still a bit of tannin, slightly fading fruit, some bell pepper and oregano. B-



Sunday went for drinks and appetizers with some friends (open windows, fans, chilly!). We carried canapes- jamon iberico de bellota, ankimo with ponzu and watermelon radish, smoked bluefish with creme fraiche. They had shrimp and stuffed mushrooms. I brought the bubbles, they had a red.


2002 Piper-Heidsieck ?Rare? Brut Champagne Rich but snappy, bright, citrus and pear, brioche. Lovely. A-


2015 Ch. Pierre 1er (St Emilion) Never heard of this before. Pretty impenetrable right now tannin, tight fruit, closed. B-/C+ for drinking now, awkward place.



Home for grey sole, yu choy, sesame spinach



2016 Battenfeld Spanier Mölsheim Riesling Trocken Nectarine, lemon, wet rocks, ginger. Powerful and focused. Nice. B+

Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C drinkable. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice.Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.


Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required