We have a small commercial vineyard/winery in the area that has produced a cloudy Pinot Noir. The vintner claims that this is acceptable, and he gives a number of reasons for the wine's condition. I think justifying a cloudy commercial wine sounds suspicious. Is it possible to NOT view cloudiness as a defect? Or is he pulling the wool over folks' eyes? Ken
Cloudy commercial wine
Jul 10, 2004
3 Replies
We have a small commercial vineyard/winery in the area that has produced a cloudy Pinot Noir. The vintner claims that this is acceptable, and he gives a number of reasons for the wine's condition. I think justifying a cloudy commercial wine sounds suspicious. Is it possible to NOT view cloudiness as a defect? Or is he pulling the wool over folks' eyes? Ken
We have a small commercial vineyard/winery in the area that has produced a cloudy Pinot Noir. The vintner claims that this is acceptable, and he gives a number of reasons for the wine's condition. I think justifying a cloudy commercial wine sounds suspicious. Is it possible to NOT view cloudiness as a defect? Or is he pulling the wool over folks' eyes? Ken
How many times are you going to post this same message? Is it you or your server?
Tom S
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required