Chateua Fayau 2001 and Clos Saint Pierre Yarra Valley Pinot Noir 2004.

I decided to honour they mother, honour thy father a couple of nights ago with a dinner. Seeing as how I'd never had them around for dinner as yet.

Anyway, I'd been trawling nicks.com.au and came across the 2001 Fayau which seemed like a good buy at $29.99AU. A gift for mother's day. It got 98/100.

When I went and got it the guy, Nick said it was a steal as it was a Cadillac rather than a sauternes. If it had been a sauternes it would probably be 3 times the price. Great wine he said, highly recommended. Good enough for me.

Then while perusing danmurphys.com.au for the weekly specials, I came across

formatting link
. Advertising the Clos Saint Pierre. It had a few notes from well know wine writers here going on about it. $15AU for a good pinot sounded good to me.

Anyway, so mum brought round the Fayau to drink. Opened it up, each had a glass. It was interesting. Lovely light golden colour. Very sweet on the nose. Some apricot, honey. Hugely sweet. A huge smack of nectarine and overipe peach I think the notes said on nicks [I couldn't figure out what the peach taste was as I haven't eaten them in years]. I picked up some stone fruit. Very complex. Quite long length. Had some interesting taste twists and turns, without being rough.

It was probably too cloying as an aperitif, I only had half a glass, and that was enough. But would have been nice with a super sweet desert. Certainly enjoyed the experience though. And at $30AU an impressive desert wine to take along to a dinner. Just wouldn't be drinking more than at most a glass at a time.

The next was the Clos St Pierre. I was not overly impressed by this. In fact if it had of had a cork I would have thought it was corked. Very thin, acidic, and literally almost fizzy on the tongue. Dad said it was good [maybe he was being polite], but I wasn't a huge fan. Was very disappointed with it. Not much on the nose, not much on the palate, even if you expected a more reserved sort of pinot.

It is a label made exclusively for Dan Murphy's by Pierre Naigeon. I also read it was in collaboration with De Bortoli, not sure to what extent.

The 2002 O'Leary Walker pinot [~$20] and even the windy peak [de bortoli ~$13], and especially the Miranda Park Norm's Pinot [~$17] Andrew put me onto I've all had recently beat this hands down. I was really looking forward to it. I'm actually hoping it was tainted [it was stelvin], though I won't be rushing out to buy it anytime soon going on the other night.

Reply to
Mat
Loading thread data ...

I'll learn how to spell properly one day.

Anyway, as a side note, the Fayau was $33 at Dan's, compared to $30 at Nick's.

That was on top of the $2 they ripped me off on the Watervale Shiraz.

I think almost all of Dan's wine trade must be in the mass produced domestics. That is almost exclusively what they advertise, and is usually the cheapest around.

Tut tut tut.

Reply to
Mat

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.