Decanter Classification of first growth Italian wines

Mar 19, 2007 7 Replies

Richard Baudains classifies the 1st growth and super second growths of Italy on p. 31 of the April 2007 issue of Decanter. This might create about as much uproar as punching a hornet nest with a stick - especially in Italy. He names 5 first growths and 15 super seconds. I will just name his 5 1st growths. At least to the extent that 1st growths tend to be expensive, many of the wines on the list well meet that consideration.



Angelo Gaja, Barbaresco, Piedmont;



Bruno Giacosa, Barbaresco, Piedmont;



Romano Dal Forno, Valpolicella, Veneto;



Tenuta dell'Ornellaia, Bolgheri, Tuscany;



Tenuta San Guido, Bolgheri, Tuscany;



Sorry, but that's completely beyond my logic - how can a producer or estate - typically marketing quite an array of wines (as opposed to the "grand vin" of a given estate in Bordeaux) - be called "growth"?

"Angelo Gaja cru classé"?! Which wine(s) from his portfolie are we talking about?

M.

After listing the "growth" just at the top, there is a brief discussion. Then there is one example of a "standout" wine at the very bottom. In the order that I gave the 1st growths:

Sori San Lorenzo, Nebbiolo, Langhe 2003;

Barbaresco Rabaja Riservi 2001;

Valpolicella Superiore 2002;

Ornellaia, Bolgheri Rosso Superiore 2004;

Sassicaia, Bolgheri 2004

No Barolos are mentioned until the list of 15 super seconds.

I am no expert on high end Italian wines, but I did find the article a bit strange.

Sori San Lorenzo 2003

"Lots of power on the palate, uncharacteristically forward.but nevertheless delivers the good s in a very difficult vintage" GBP157.20......bit steep ?

I agree I found the two articles difficult to get my head around, probably due to my lack of knowledge, but one sentence caught my eye.

Page 36, " of the 15 second growths, eight are white wines."

John T

Haaaaaaaa, fantastic Joe Beppe !

You forgot the t> You guys missed the article on the cheapwinez site listing the cru classe of > plonkdom:

You guys missed the article on the cheapwinez site listing the cru classe of plonkdom:

First growth: Best Western Golden Chablis Charles Shaw Gamay Noir

Second Growths: David Bruce's Pre 1990 wines Inept Vineyards "le Quaff du Jour"

Third Growths: Gallo Thunderbird early picking Dead Gentile Rouge--Austrailia Il Cemento Blanco d' Blanco Spumante

4th & 5th growths: Over 60 wines who advertise: Full Page==4th Cru Classe Half Page= 5th Growth Cru Classe

Vin ordonaire exceptional:

1/4 page.

Italian wine is not like F_____. This is idiotic.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required