Merlot in Sideways

why was Miles so dead set against Merlot? Has it lost its mass appeal or just a personal quirk of the character?

Reply to
txs
Loading thread data ...

Miles is an exageration of an insecure wine-snob assh*le.

I think the movie might have elevated Pinot Noir to a similar kind of mass-appeal as Merlot has enjoyed for quite some time, but it's just a movie, and it's not about wine.

Hint: Jack is as messed-up as Miles is.

Dana

Reply to
Dana H. Myers

Merlot is increasingly joining the chardonnay bracket as "Anything but that". So its becoming untrendy. When someone tells me they only drink merlot I remind myself never to get trapped on a desert island with them.

Merlot traditionally has been a bit of a safe wine. Goes with most things. Is fairly innocuous, and is often said to be the white drinkers red or the everyman red because most ppl will like it, even non-red drinkers [and beer drinkers too I've noticed]. Which is not strictly true, very early on both myself and my father got put off merlot.

Here in Australia, and we had a bit of a broo-ha-ha in this group a little while ago about merlot being over-sweet, thin crap, it is usually over sweet, thin crap, lacking any length, intensity or character.

However, I have been somewhat converted by a Mr Andrew Goldfinch and his lovely partner Jodie. At their tasty dinner they were nice enough to invite us to, he cracked a Leconfield Coonawarra 2002 Merlot.

It was a pretty big wine. It had been decanted which helped a lot. If I remember correctly it was a huge, thick wine, with a lovely mouth feel, a long finish with the occaisional hint of pepper. I didn't take notes and we drank another wine at the same time so I can't be more precise, I may even be mixing the two up [they were both excellent, Charles Melton Nine Popes 2001] but I do recall thinking it couldn't be a merlot. Both myself and the other half who doesn't usually like red wine, enjoyed it immensely. I believe its scored high 90s in a number of tastings by various Oz wine big wigs. Very very nice.

So in conclusion I think merlot is increasingly passe, and being that it is fairly easy to make so everyone makes it, and a lot of bad examples are around, a lot of ppl get put off it.

Reply to
Mat

All true.

Also Miles also had pschological problems with his ex-wife and another Merlot, Cheval Blanc, both of which seemd to be stopping him from moving on. Maybe I am reading too much into the script, but that may also have been a factor.

Reply to
Steve Slatcher

Sideways is also based on an unpublished novel by wine geek Rex Pickett. Miles' taste in large part mirror's Pickett's own, as he says in this interview on Fresh Air with Terry Gross:

formatting link
Pickett acknowledges he doesn't like merlot, saying it is flabby and best used as a blending grape. Then he goes on to a name a few merlots he thinks are well made.

Reply to
Steve Timko

Not unpublished since April '04:

formatting link

Cheval Blanc, like most St-Emilions, is a mix of Cab Franc and Merlot (typically about 50/50). Of course, since Miles disses Cab Franc too, the point still stands.

Mark Lipton

Reply to
Mark Lipton

Cheval Blanc is coming from Saint Emilion and then isn't a pure Merlot. It's using Cabernet franc (i don't know the english word) and Merlot...

Reply to
Une bévue

I sort-of knew that, but thought Ceval Blanc had an unusually high Merlot content. On checking though iI had remembered the wrong way round; it is 60% Cab Franc.

Reply to
Steve Slatcher

Steve Slatcher wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com:

But the irony stands due to the cab franc bashing as well.

Has anyone tasted a cab Franc out of CA? Are they as bad as the movie makes them out to be. I am a big fan of Loire valley products but the only encounter with anyone with US knowledge assured me that Cab Franc by itself was "undrinkable" and harsh- does not sound like a Bourgeuill to me.

Reply to
jcoulter

blended seems to stand for "assemblage" (french)

i wonder if u have a way, in english, to make the difference between year-blended wines, vineplants blended wines and both kind of ?

Reply to
Une bévue

David Coffaro makes a nice example. Most of his reds are blends, and his Cab Franc is (I think) no exception, but I don't have the bottle handy. Dave is in the Dry Creek area, and his wines are usually very fruit-forward and typically low-tannin; drinkable from the get-go. I've had the pleasure of tasting his 4-month old barrel samples, and I was amazed at how approachable they were.

I take any generalization like your friend produced with a grain of salt - there are talented people in every wine-producing area doing marvelous things with almost any grape they can get their hands on; the fun is finding them!

Regards, Dean

Reply to
DPM

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.