New Years Dinner--TN

Greeted the New Year with a large dose of football, as do all red-blooded Americans, along with continual infusions of food.

Started the morning with traditional eggs Benedict and bloody marys. Drifted into the pre-dinner nosh of smoked salmon canapes with Grey Goose vodka martini.

Dinner was a magnificent prime rib roast (excellent, juicy, rare, tender), Yorkshire pudding (over-cooked, dry, bready), spinach salad with cranberry, roast pecans, apples and raspberry vinagrette.

With dinner, a 1994 Chateau Beyechevelle. Checked my Cellar! Online for TNs and found Parker underwhelmed by the vintage declaring it "weedy", without fruit, short-lived. 82 pts. My impression was of pencil lead, leather, a very light vanilla tinge, but no berry flavors discernible. Still tannic to my taste. Bitter, dark and brooding. Better than Parker saw it, but not the joyful wine I sought.

After dinner sipping, keeping with the Cab Sauv, I pulled a bottle of '98 Pine Ridge Napa Valley Stag's Leap District CS. Huge nose of butterscotch and blueberry pie--not just berries, but the whole pie with dough and sugary sweetness (not quite ala mode, but close). In the mouth, the blueberries continue along with the pie dough sensation and a dose of caramel/vanilla. Tannins still apparent with a bit of talc on the tongue afterward. Should last a lot longer. Compared to the Beychevelle, here was a bright, flavorful, exciting wine. Clear contrast to me between Euro and Calif styles.

HNY to all!

Ed Rasimus Fighter Pilot (USAF-Ret) "When Thunder Rolled" Smithsonian Institution Press ISBN #1-58834-103-8

Reply to
Ed Rasimus
Loading thread data ...

FWIW, the highest rating that Parker has ever given a Beychevelle is 92pts for the 1986. This Chateau has under performed for years. Bi!!

Reply to
RV WRLee

And the 82.

That notwithstanding, I have enjoyed many a bottle of the 1975.

Reply to
Bill Spohn

And I bought the 1998 en primeur, based on the cask tasting in March

1999.

M.

Reply to
Michael Pronay

And the 1948 and the 1953. My original search was incomplete. Bi!!

Reply to
RV WRLee

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.