Oregon Pinot Noir Tasting Notes

For the holiday weekend, I picked up several Oregon Pinot Noirs, rolled out the grill, and enjoyed the moment. I wanted to share these notes with you.

----------------------------------------------------

  1. 2003 Stevenson-Barrie Pinot Noir

Appellation: Willamette Valley, Oregon Alcohol: 14% Bottling Notes: Unfined

Color and Appearance: Clear, vibrant ruby red. Insanely viscous -- long, drawn-out legs continued for a full six minutes after tasting(!).

Aroma: Cherry, strawberry, leather, oak, smoke, and clove. Presented lovely bouquet upon opening, and became much more complex with breathing.

Taste and Finish: Fruit-forward berry. Soft, succulent, silky on the palate. Balanced acids. Smooth, gracefully waning finish. The tiniest zest of pepper at the very end.

Pairing Suggestions: Grilled lamb stuffed with rosemary sprigs and garlic. Cedar plank BBQ'd salmon. Simple greens with oil and vinegar.

Overall Opinion: This is from a recently-new producer, and the first wine of their label that I've ever tried. What a fantastic wine. Despite its initially robust, oaky character, it opened up and showed a lovely feminine quality you'd typically expect from a Pinot Noir. It's nice to find a "gentle" Oregon Pinot Noir given the "cherry bomb" trends exhibited by some local wineries.

----------------------------------------------------

  1. 2001 Iris Hill Pinot Noir

Appellation: Oregon Alcohol: 11.9%

Color and Appearance: Light ruby red, very clear.

Aroma: Bright cherry and wild berry.

Taste and Finish: Brief fruitiness was overpowered by a tart, acidic finish. Additional breathing only accentuated these characteristics.

Pairing Suggestions: Tums chewable antacids.

Overall Opinion: Disappointing. Many Oregon Pinots that need mellowing do so after four years in the bottle. This one, however, already seems well past its prime, and I couldn't help but think it was this way to begin with. 11.9% is quite low alcohol content for such a P.N. -- which leads me to wonder if the vintner didn't try diluting it down to cut the acidity.

----------------------------------------------------

  1. Cardwell Hill Cellars Pinot Noir

Appellation: Willamette Valley, Oregon Alcohol: 13.1%

Color and Appearance: Deep red. Moderate legs.

Aroma: Oak and berry, but a distinct sweat/musty/geranium odor soon came to the forefront.

Taste and Finish: Surprisingly soft and supple. Nice cherry notes and a touch of spice.

Pairing Suggestions: None.

Overall Opinion: This is a recently-new producer. Unfortunately, I would not recommend it. The geranium odors are indicative of oxidation from not enough Sulphur and/or unsanitary conditions during fermentation. 90 minutes of breathing helped a bit, but this wine's fate was sealed prior to bottling.

----------------------------------------------------

  1. 2003 Stag Hollow Pinot Noir

Appellation: Yamhill-Carlton (Willamette Valley), Oregon Alcohol: 14.9% Bottling Notes:

Color and Appearance: Brilliant red-maroon. Ample viscosity with long legs and sheets.

Aroma: Quite complex, a nasal treat that continued to surprise for well over an hour as it began to breathe. Initial waves of cherry, smoke, and earth eventually gave way to richer, spicier plum, vanilla, and leather.

Taste and Finish: Rich and smooth at each tasting interval. Medium length finish, smooth the entire time. Well-balanced acids.

Pairing Suggestions: BBQ grilled chicken with pan-seared mushrooms. Zucchini grilled in olive oil with fresh margarom, parsley, and oregano. Italian paysan loaf spread with brie.

Overall Opinion: A wine like this demands its own timeline and space in which to open up. Uncork, decant, and watch patiently from a distance. Sample, and wait. Repeat multiple times over 90 minutes, and serve.

----------------------------------------------------

  1. 2005 Evasham Wood Pinot Noir

Appellation: Willamette Valley, Oregon Alcohol: 13% Price: $15

Color and Appearance: A dark, ruby red. Thick in appearance. Long legs quickly dissipated. A bit of sediment along the inner edge of the glass, but hardly enough to bother over.

Aroma: Earthy, mineral, plum and oak.

Taste and Finish: Jammy, with a lengthy, moderately spicey finish.

Pairing Suggestions: Grilled lamb or chicken. This one has enough zest to be compatible with traditional Shiraz pairings -- peppery, grilled, heavier/richer red meats and dishes, etc.

Overall Opinion: A lovely wine, especially given the price. I noted the sediment, and simply reverted to the Stevenson-Barrie -- in that the vintner perhaps chose to leave "all the good things" in the wine and forego fining.

----------------------------------------------------

Whether this weekend is a three-day holiday for you or not (Labor Day here in the States), I hope you will all take a moment to relax and enjoy your favorite wine.

Cheers,

David Anderson OregonWines.com

Reply to
Dave
Loading thread data ...

Evesham Wood is the only one of these I was familiar with. I've generally liked their wines. This made me realize some friends and I never followed through on an idea for some blind OR Pinots, specifically Evesham Wood "vs." St Innocent, since I believe they both bottle some of the same vineyards (7 Springs and Temperance). Thanks for notes.

Reply to
DaleW

Can;t help but notice the range of alcohol in those iwnes; 11.9% at one end,

14.9% at the other!

Reply to
Ric

Also notice that the high alcohol ones are all from 2003 -- a long warm growing season in Oregon and elsewhere, that produced a lot of very ripe (read: high sugar/high alcohol) grapes.

Reply to
AyTee

Hi Ric and AyTee,

Yeah... sometimes I wonder if the vintners here have an alterior motive, but... :)

I believe federal law mandates a wine can contain up to 14.9% alcohol. Above 15%, it falls into a class of fortified/dessert wines. I find this designation odd, as in recent years, specialized strains of yeast have been developed (albeit for malt beverages) that can push alcohol content upwards of 25% without fortification!

Many Oregon red wines tend to contain higher alcohol content. Recent warmer summers have no doubt helped them along, but even so, my impression is that in cooler years, some of the vineyards are willing to risk leaving the grapes hang for an extra week or two (knowing that rainy season could strike at any time and potentially ruin the crop). I do recall that 2003 resulted in a relative glut of some really good wines.

Tonight is no exception -- enjoying a Freja Cellars 2003 Pinot Noir (*only* 13%). Lovely currant and bright cherry, oak and earth. A tad peppery. Fantastic with the turkey, basil, and red bell pepper meatloaf we baked this evening. Also great with fresh focaccia and sliced, aged Asiago cheese. ssh! Don't tell my dietician.

Cheers,

David

Reply to
Dave

[...]

At 15% and above, wine is taxed at about 3 times the rate of "normal" alcohol wines. Correct. The law dates from a time before the alcohol-tolerant yeasts were developed, under the assumption that any wine with greater than about 14% must be fortified. At least that is my understanding of the justification for this particular class designation in the USA.

There may also be a fashion issue. Big wines are in style for the moment, and high alcohol is part of that.

Andy

Reply to
AyTee

Aha! Of course - the reason for staying under the 15% bar no doubt has less to do with designation, and more to do with good old fashioned tax evasion. :)

It's interesting to note that in the past few years, an incredibly alcohol-tolerant brewing yeast was developed. It was developed by Wyeast here in Hood River, can produce beers upwards of 25%, and recently was featured on the commercial side by Sam Adams in one of their "specialty" ales.

It would be curious to note how 25% ales fall given the Federal laws... and how increasing production of such ales might affect designations and or tax rates down the road...

Cheers,

David

Reply to
Dave

Omigod! Ale with 25% alcohol. Scary.

Reply to
AyTee

I've heard it was quite good, though at $100 US per bottle I passed on it. That's for 24 ounces. I like good beer, but I'd rather spend a few bucks on some Corsendonk dubbel.

Though the Sam Adams was packaged in a mini copper (or copper-looking) brew kettle...

-ben

Reply to
Ben Snyder

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.