TN: Bet dinner-'89 Bdx, '75 Bdx, '88 Aussie, '92 Burg

Last June there was a discussion on another forum about 2005 Bordeaux prices. My friend Matt posted some incredible opening prices on some First Growths, and our English buddy Ian felt they couldn't maintain, with a bold prediction of a big drop in one year. I felt the prices were high, but doubted bubble burst within a year. Ian and I entered into a bet - if 3 selected 1sts (Mouton, Latour, and Margaux) dropped

20% in one year, Ian won. If they increased 10% or more, I won. In between, no winner. Prize was to be a mature Bdx worth $150+. Well, the Mouton was a dog, but Margaux appreciated nicely, and Latour soared. It came in at 11%.

Ian was a good sport about his narrow loss, but it seemed silly to exchange a bottle. So instead we agreed that Ian would contribute a First Growth, and myself, Matt, and Arv (who was designated judge) bring other wines from same vintage to a dinner. So last night we met at Vice Versa in Manhattan. Arv's wife Jen joined us, as did our friend David who was in US for a big Zachys auction he helped set up (he said prices were very strong Friday).

Food was pretty good, though place was very loud. I had a half order of strozzapreti ( ''Strangled Priest'' pasta) with duck ragu, and suckling pig with grilled endive. There wasn't a dog in the bunch of wines:

1992 Potinet-Ampeau "Perrieres" Meursault 1er So at first pour this was almost clear, with light butterscotch over pear fruit. But in literally a minute colored had darkened considerably, and some nutty oxidative notes entered. Quite drinkable, but I felt it was dying in glass. But the funny thing was after the oxidative notes started, it kind of hung in stasis for a couple hours. A couple sips with the cheese plate were about the same as those 5 minutes after pouring. Pear, spice, mineral, hazelnuts; too thin to really be taken for a 1er, but ok. B/B-

1989 Certan de May (Pomerol) I had decided to double-decant this before getting on train. And good thing- corked to the max. Luckily I had one more bottle, and decanted it (though it didn't have time to stand first). Very sweet black plum fruit, a hint of mocha. There's just a touch of barnyard after a while, not intrusive. Smooth, although maybe a little less lush texturally than a true top Pomerol, I still found this quite enjoyable, and mourn the corked bottle. Holds up well over 2 hours. A-/ B+

1975 Le Gay (Pomerol) A little bretty, high acids, noticable tannins. David says this is "very 1975" and I can see what he means. Broad-shouldered, brawny, top especially long. I don't like as much as a recent '75 L'Evangile, but still a good showing. Pomerols have generally been my favorite '75s. B

1989 Beychevelle I'm not usually a big Beychevelle fan, but I like this a lot. Good acidity, resolved tannins, redder fruit than other wines this night. Lots of herbs and cedar, maybe most "a pointe" wine of evening. A-

1989 Grand Puy Lacoste (Pauillac) Softer than expected, seemingly pretty mature, plum and blackberry fruit, low acid, light tannins. B+

1989 Lynch Bages (Pauillac) I've always liked this wine, but this is one of the better showings. A very Mouton-esque exoticism, lush, spicy black fruits, lots of coffee aromas. Entering plateau, but plenty of structure. A-

1989 Lafite Rothschild (Pauillac) Young and trying to burst out, a thoroughbred straining at the leads Lovely rich and dense fruit, just developing its secondary aromas, but clean cedar/lead pencil and some earth. This needs time, but classic Lafite -elegant yet powerful. A

1988 Henschke Mount Edelstone Shiraz I think I don't have any Australians cellared outside some Penfolds

389s from the 90s, but it's wines like this (as well as some Yarra Yerring, Parker Estates, etc ) that make me realize that's a mistake. Rich and ripe, yet with structure and backbone, and some elegance to boot. Nothing over the top here, sweet but not the least bit candied. Lovely wine. A-

Fun evening with a nice crew. Timing was perfect- I strolled up 9th Ave on a lovely fall evening and got to Lincoln Center as Betsy came out. Thanks to Ian for his good sportsmanship, and to all for their great wine contributions.

Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency

Reply to
DaleW
Loading thread data ...

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.