TN: good to disappointing (Burg, Loire, MSR)

2004 Marc Colin "La Combe" Bourgogne Sweet pear fruit with a bit of apple blossom and vanilla, nice flavors, but it somehow seems a bit empty. I don't expect basic Bourgognes to be models of concentration, but this borders on dilution, and there's no need for that in this vintage. B-

2002 JJ Christoffel Urziger Wurzgarten Riesling Kabinett Due to plastic corks (some bottles have plastic, some natural, this was an extruded cork) I'm trying to finish off these. This seems sweeter than last bottle, very peachy with just a hint of lime. Not complex,but a good deal at well under $10. Went well with some chicken-jalapeno sausage, as well as grilled (storebought) polenta and squash. B

2004 Clos Roche Blanche Gamay (Touraine) I'm usually the first (well, in the first 100) to sing the praises of CRB, but a previous bottle didn't thrill me, though I liked. But I didn't finish this over 3 nights, and the rest went into vinegar crock. Good acidity, nice bright raspberrym and strawberry fruit. But what was a nice herby edge before has gone into a somewhat weedy/funky green thing. Reminds me of houseplants- or maybe houseplant food. Other bottle was better, this is for me a C.

Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.

Reply to
DaleW
Loading thread data ...

Thanks for the warning, Dale. I think I might pass on this year's version and put my shekels into more Bojo instead. And I'm gonna have to find some Christoffel, too.

Mark Lipton

Reply to
Mark Lipton

"DaleW" wrote in news:1158857336.258412.253180 @d34g2000cwd.googlegroups.com:

It is interesting to read this tasting note. I found a great wine shop in Barcelona that sells by mail to all Spain and specialises in Burgundy wines. Now I am in love with Burgundy.

With wines from this shop I arranged two tastings and purchased a few wines for my own consumption.

Marc Colin Chassagne-Montrachet 2004 PC Les Encegnieres was dominated by oak and, while had good white fruit and nice acidity, I found it too obvious.

Marc Colin Chassagne-Montrachet 2004 PC Les Caillerets was too austere, a bit acidic from the start and took too much time to display some character. Too much oak also.

Marc Colin Meursault 2002 PC Les Charmes was also completely closed, it was wide in the mouth and very young. Not bad but not cheap also.

Marc Colin Saint-Aubin 2004 PC En Remilly was clearly overoaked and disjointed. At 24 euros I am not buying more bottles.

As a result, in any of the tastings these wines were the best of the league, and I clearly preferred a Chateau de la Maltroye 2004 CM PC to the two PC by Marc Colin and even the Saint-Aubin, even if the price was just 25 euros.

And for the price of the Meursault, I strongly prefer the Ramonet 2004 PC Boudriotte which I thought was truly fantastic.

Best,

S.

Reply to
Santiago

Disappointed to hear about the CRB. I usually like it for fall drinking.

Reply to
Lawrence Leichtman
Reply to
Anders Tørneskog

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.