TN: Great Gruner (plus others)

Aug 13, 2006 4 Replies

A few from last few days:



2002 Huards Cour-Cheverny On day one I kind of liked the bitter lemon and canteloupe notes , though it didn't seem to have the depth of the Cazin. OK wine, but surprisingly (to me, for a high acid wine), it seemed to totally fall apart overnight in the fridge. Get the Cazin. B-


2001 Rabasse Charavin Rasteau Cotes du Rhone Villages Big ripe CdR, with red (raspberry and cherry) fruit overlaid with herbs, leather, and a little wood. I probably enjoyed this a little less than it deserved, just frankly the wrong wine with a light summer meal. Probably a B- for my enjoyment now, but would have certainly scored higher with a hearty winter meal.


2005 Dönnhoff Riesling QbA (Nahe) Peaches and lime zest, off-dry with balancing acidity. Surprisingly good match with some bulgogi. With some hype about the 2005s I had maybe hoped for something more stunning, but this is still a fine value- quality wise about the same as the 2004 or 2002. B+/B


2004 Nigl "Privat" Gruner Veltliner (Kremstal) Damn, this is good. Initially served too cold, as it slowly warmed (slowly- a shockingly cool night for NY in August) layers of complexity tumbled out. Herbs, white pepper, lentils, lemon and green apple fruit, citrus zest- all bound up in a large frame and backed by a firm acidic spine. Betsy had flown back from a NC concert Saturday AM, a Gourmet mag she had picked up on plane had a menu for grilled breaded pork chops, veggie kabobs in a vinaigrette, and a quinoa salad. Betsy substituted veal chops for the pork, great match for the GV. A fine Gruner with plenty of potential to age, but oh so good now. A-/A



Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.



Dale, what do you know about the aging potential of Romorantin? Is it possible that Cazin's is simply an outlier wrt lifetime?

Mark Lipton

Had this in our large tasting line-up in July last year, my notes reading very much along yours, scored 93/100.

Try to get the 2005 which 1) comes also in screwcaps, and 2) is even better (scored a stunning 97 four weeks ago).

M.

Mark, I can't really attest to anything beyond the Cazin (and the oldest Cazin I've had was the '96 Renaissance, which is tasty but young now). But in any case I prefer the 2002 Cazin now, so no reason to buy the Huard!

thanks for tip, Michael. It doesn't seem to available yet in US, but will keep my eyes peeled.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required