[TN] Jean's Birthday wines ('08 SUH QbA and '04 Chave StJ)

Jul 27, 2009 5 Replies

To celebrate Jean's birthday today (discretion forbids me from mentioning years), I cooked her a dinner of smoked duck, cold borscht, sweet corn and orzo with a light salad.



As an aperitif and with the soup and corn:


2008 St. Urbans Hof Mosel Riesling QbA ($15.49) nose: flowers and citrus palate: light, lithe, zesty lime, off dry

Our first exposure to the '08 vintage in the Mosel was a good experience. Having had this wine in previous vintages ('05 and '06 IIRC), this year's version has more zip and is lighter on its feet. If a QbA can be this fun, I can't wait for the lower Prädikat QmPs.



With the duck, etc.



2004 J. L Chave St. Joseph nose: stones, bright, juicy, red berry fruit, a hint of meatiness palate: medium weight, bright, juicy, some complexity

Jean had asked for a Crozes with the duck, but our only Crozes at the moment is an '06 Graillot that is nowehere near ready. In truth, this wine was nowhere near ready, too, but still quite pleasant to drink. Jean complained of the simpleness and a lack of depth, but I suspect that another 5-10 years will produce a much more interesting wine than the one we had tonight. A decent match with smoked duck, though. Half the bottle retained for subsequent evaluation.



Mark Lipton


Happy Birthday Jean! The QbA sounds very nice. I just got a bottle of the '04 Chave estate St-Jo (Grapes closeout of lone bottles), will hold for a while based on this.

LIke the Chave. Have 3 bottles of Offerus 01 and 03, judging from your comments they could use some time as well? Joseph Coulter Joseph Coulter Cruises and Vacations

formatting link

The Offerus is generally regarded as an earlier drinker than the estate St Jo. I'd guess the '01 is pretty ready (never had, but Gilman lists as 2006-2010). I thought '03 could use some time a couple years ago, have a lone bottle I'm thinking within next couple years.

We had the Offerus from 2003 at a wine tasting at Casa Sena in Santa Fe and it will need a lot more time. 5-7 years.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required