I found your article interesting, did they say what the problem was. Stephen. uk
June 29, 2003, 2:00PM Have you seen this extract
formatting link
Texas ruling favours out-of-state wineries AUSTIN -- Out-of-state wineries can now ship wine directly to Texas wine lovers. Texas law prohibits such shipments, but a federal appeals court ruling found that the rules were discriminatory and treated out-of-state wineries unfairly. The ruling, issued on Thursday, upholds U.S. District Judge Melissa Harmon's
2002 ruling in which she said the state law violated the Constitution's interstate commerce clause. The state appealed Harmon's ruling to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. The ruling was in response to a lawsuit filed by three Texas wine lovers who wanted more choices when buying wine. In Texas, consumers must buy wine directly from retailers based on a law that's been in place since Prohibition ended in 1933. The state law, however, allows Texas wineries to ship directly to in-state consumers. The wineries ship up to 25,000 gallons of wine a year. "This is a good precedent that breaks down these artificial barriers," Mark Harwell, the Houston lawyer that represented the plaintiffs. The Texas Alcohol and Beverage Commission hasn't yet decided how it will respond to the high-court ruling. Commission Chairman John Steen said in a story for Saturday's edition of Austin American-Statesman that the commissioners will consult individually with the commission's general counsel on Monday. The state has until July 10 to request a review of the appeal by all the judges on the court. Texas residents could start ordering wine from other states immediately if the state doesn't take action by the