Yes, there is a scientific answer
Christine Charlson, WCPO Contributor
4:05 AM, Mar 13, 2015
3 hours ago
With St. Patrick's Day upon us, we asked a doctor if age affects how
much we can safely drink. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
Copyright 2015 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material
may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
(BUTTON) Show Caption (BUTTON) Hide Caption
(BUTTON) Previous (BUTTON) Next
It's almost St. Patrick's Day. To celebrate, you may be planning on
heading to a local pub to toss back a few green beers with friends.
Problem is, last year's green beers left you feeling pretty miserable
the next day, and, for lack of a better word...green.
You drank like a champ back in college, right? So what happened?
It seems for many of us, the older we get, the less we can drink. Why
We sought out Dr. Daniel Schauer, who's in the division of general
internal medicine at University of Cincinnati, for an answer to that
Why does it seem like the older we get the less we can drink?
As people get older, they break down alcohol more slowly in the liver,
and if people develop liver problems it kind of exacerbates that
problem even more. So the same amount of alcohol they used to drink has
a greater effect on them than it did previously, because they're
breaking it down more slowly. People also tend to drink less as they
get older, so they have a lower tolerance than they did when they were
So we get out of practice and lose our tolerance?
It was more frequent drinking that led to tolerance. Tolerance doesn't
mean it changes your blood alcohol level and you're less intoxicated,
it just means you're more tolerant to the effects. So it takes more
alcohol to reach the same effects on your body than it did before.
Dr. Daniel Schauer
Does the same hold true in both men and women?
Women tend to be smaller than men, so their tolerance is usually lower.
They also tend to have less muscle mass than men, so less total body
water. Which brings me to the third reason for both men and women: less
total body water. As people age, they lose muscle mass and the
percentage of body fat increases. That leads to the body having less
overall water, so when you drink alcohol you have higher alcohol
concentrations. Especially in the elderly, that's an important reason
why they can't drink like they used to.
Any other reasons why we can't drink like we did in college?
I was talking to my wife about it, and she said one reason is because
we have jobs and we have kids now. We can't sleep till noon.
What's a sign that you've had too many green beers?
When your friends tell you is always a good start. I think it's one of
those things that people don't recognize themselves when they are
drinking. It sneaks up on people especially if they're not used to
drinking much. My advice would be moderation and definitely listen to
What about shots?
Shots are just a more concentrated form of alcohol, so it gets into
your bloodstream more quickly. The ability to do shots goes down as you
age. So do shots responsibly.
How about that nasty 'green beer hangover' the next day? It never
seemed to be that bad when we were younger.
It goes back to less water in the body as we get older. You get
dehydrated because alcohol makes you produce more urine. It's a
diuretic, kind of like caffeine. It also irritates your stomach,
increasing the production of stomach acid, and that can lead to the
nausea you feel the next day. In some alcoholic beverages, they have
something called a congener, and they're kind of like flavoring in
alcoholic beverages. They're in dark liquors like brandies or whiskies,
but they're not in clear alcohol like vodka or gin. But they contribute
Hmmm, I seem to recall getting a hangover from vodka...what happened?
Any alcohol can give you a hangover, but alcohol with congeners can be
What's your advice for people who sampled a bit too much green beer?
Drink a lot of water. It's a complicated answer for a hangover, because
I would say take ibuprofen, but you don't really want to mix
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medication and alcohol because that
increases your risk of ulcers. It's something we all do, you wake up,
feel hung over and take ibuprofen or you take Tylenol. And Tylenol with
drinking is also bad because it's bad for your liver. So neither one of
those is a great option, but everyone does it. But the best thing to do
is to rehydrate. Drink lots of water and go back to bed.
What's some good advice for people if they're going out drinking on St.
Don't forget to eat and stay hydrated.
- posted 3 years ago