well, to me anyway!
'98 Chateauneuf du Pape, Font de Michelle First time I've tried this. As hoped, it was only starting to drowse, not fully asleep yet. Still, quite austere, with a big and quite fine structure, overlayed with gobs of cassis, tobacco, tar, and a very long finish. I believe in 8-10 years this will be a great wine indeed. Reminiscent of the wonderful '89.
'95 Vacqueyras, Dom Amouriers "Les Genestes" This was an experiment in oaking by the late (and lamented) Jocelyn Chudzikiewitz. He explained to me that certain importers were "pressuring" him to produce a more international style; and although he wasn't in favor, the economics made him make this effort. (Apparently it succeeded, as Dom Amouriers is now widely available in the US.) I was unsure of this on first tasting (in '97), but decided to see what a few years might do. Sadly my first impressions were correct. Quite mean, with simple plummy fruit and an unpleasantly woody finish, I judge this is going nowhere. Perhaps the vintage was insufficiantly strong to support the experiment...
-E