Back to 1975

Feb 24, 2005 15 Replies

Hello; One of our youngsters was born 1975, so turns a ripe and mellow 30 this summer. I have started to find wines from that year - port is a natural as it was declared vintage by many of the good producers, and our own hawker stocks some in their treasure chest. However, apart from first growth Haut Medocs and Petrus, which wines are still alive and drinkable today? I would hazard some Bourg reds, perhaps some Mosel Rieslings, but I´m uncertain. Hints are eagerly accepted.



Cheers



Nils Gustaf


I still have several 1975 Rieslings from Germany. If properly stored, most of auslesen and higher from the better estates, especially in the Mosel/Saar still are drinking very well and many will last. At the auslese level, I have tasted the following good ones within the past few years:

Bernkasteler Doctor,Thansh; Brauneberger Juffer,Thanish; Graacher Himmelreich, J.J. Prum; Wehlener Sonnenuhr( regular and long gold capsule),J.J. Prum; Maximin Grunhauser Herrenberg

I am sure there must be many more.

My mailbox is always full to avoid spam. To contact me, erase snipped-for-privacy@webtv.net from my email address. Then add snipped-for-privacy@yahoo.com . I do not check this box every day, so post if you need a quick response.

Funny that you mention it - I asked the same question not too long ago. I ended up buying a 1975 Gruaud-Larose on the recommendation of others in the group.

The relevant thread is here:

formatting link

Léoville-L.C., Pichon-Lalande (the only vintage vinified by Michel Delon of LLC, btw), Ducru, Latour.

Hands off! Totally rotten vintage. Even DRCs undrinkable.

Yes!

You're welcome.

M.

75 claret, esp LLC good auslese my eldest is 30 this year as well, musy have been the hot summer of 75

JT

The hot summer was 1976. The summer of 1975 wasn't hot*), but also on the dry side.

*) in Europe.

M.

Another vote for '75 Leoville Las Cases. Had a bottle 2 weeks ago for my girlfriend's 30th - it was great, and matched beautifully with a rack of lamb.

The advise from the previous thread on this group was most helpful with this choice. It was also surprising how reasonable the price was relative to current vintages.

dale m.

Hi Everyone,

I don't think I've posted in this group before, but enjoying reading it quite a bit. I was surprised to read the post below that a 30 year old Riesling could not only be good, but in this case great. I thought white wines were usually consumed young - is that true most of the time?

Thanks for educating me =)

Joe Costlow

"Cygnus" skrev i meddelandet news: snipped-for-privacy@comcast.com...

In fact, many whites will age beautifully, as good as reds - not only the great ´Rieslings of Mosel, but also some of the good white Bourgognes. Personally, I have enjoyed Rieslings from 1982 and 1989 that were a pure delight - full of vitality and vibrancy (vibrancy? sorry about that). I have also had the pleasure of tasting a Corton Charlemange from 1982 which went extraordinarliy well with the warmed-up left-overs served in that restaurant, in a very imposing castle on the countryside of Côte-de-Nuits. It is amazing what some restaurants get away with, and at what prices. But the wine was good. However, this doesn´t many that any Chard will stay about for 20+ years, or that you´ll be able to drink any RIesling that is allowed to vote. We had a Riesling Gustav Lorentz, ALsace, 1983, at a tasting earlier this year, which in my excellent opinion was way over the top. GUstav Lorentz is a good producer, though on the expensive side, but the difference between this wine and a similarly aged Riesling from Dr Losen was astounding.

HTH Cheers Nils Gustaf

Salut/Hi Cygnus,

le/on Sun, 27 Feb 2005 01:11:48 -0500, tu disais/you said:-

Many more white wines can be drunk with some bottle age than you might think. It's a common truism that red wines need age and white wines don't. Like all truisms, there is a basis of fact.

OK. As a general rule, sweet wines not only live a long time, but many, especially those whose sweetness comes from "Noble Rot" (aka botrytis), improve dramatically. No, let's be more precise. They _change_ dramatically, losing fresh fruitiness, and gaining depth and complexity. Young sweet botrytised wines are so delicious that it is unfair only to say that they _improve_.

Sweet white wines whose sweetness comes about because the grapes are dried by letting them hang on the vine a long time, or because the wine maker has stopped their fermentation by adding alcohol, are less imporoved by age, in general. (In reds of that type, don't forget port).

Amongst European dry whites, some demand aging, notably the classic whites made from Chardonnay in Burgundy, and the wines made from the Chenin Blanc on the Loire and the great Rhine, Mosel, Saar and Ruwer wines. Lesser wines can take more aging than you might think, but may not necessarily be improved by it. I think it's true to say that Italian whites resist aging less well as they lose the fresh attractiveness they have when young, without gaining much complexity. But I'd suggest that even from Italy there are VERY few wines which won't keep a couple of years.

Hope the above continues the process.

yes 76 was the really hot one, but in the UK 75 was also wonderful

Good. Now, where do I find some old Rieslings? For Bordeaux, I try to hang out on the iDealWine.com (usually losing the bids to somebody present in the auction hall, which, I might add, has saved me considerable sums so far), but where are the old Germans? Anything similar on a .de web site?

Cheers

Nils Gustaf

Hi Nils! you may want to try

formatting link
Anders

"Nils Gustaf Lindgren" skrev i melding news:pcmUd.18464$ snipped-for-privacy@newsb.telia.net...

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required