Breezaire vs Whisperkool

It seems to have been a while since this has been addressed, so which do you recommend as better performing and more reliable? I will be cooling a 4x6x8 foot closet in Houston -- lots of heat and humidity. Am also curious about your thoughts on sizing. Are the smaller units rated for 265/300 cu feet (Breezaire/Whisperkool) sufficient for this

192 cu foot closet, or should I spend a couple hundred more dollars for the next size up rated for 650 cu feet? I worry about a smaller unit being overworked in Houston. Is this a valid concern or will the smaller units be sufficient for a properly built closet? Thanks for your replies.
Reply to
BGManne
Loading thread data ...

snipped-for-privacy@hotmail.com (BGManne) wrote in news:e947e543.0406241456.7cbdf6b8 @posting.google.com:

I am assuming that your house has central air in addition to the unit you describe. If so you are more than adequate.

Reply to
jcoulter

I have a similarly sized space in North Florida, which is also hot and humid, and I have been using the Breezaire small unit for it with no problem for a few years.

Good luck.

Marc

Reply to
Marc Branch

'thought this might be of some help to you ... (while 95% of our clientele is outside the state of texas, we have been building on-site rooms here in houston for years and are familiar with our unique climate)

we do source every line of american and european equipment, the various "brands" are not routinely interchangeable ... each is designed to meet certain criteria of a specific application and a given client's parameters. oversizing can be as counterproductive as inadequate ventilation or insufficient capacity.

first and foremost, room preparation is critical. none will perform efficiently absent proper construction. please visit our primary site,

formatting link
and click on "do-it-yourself". (
formatting link
)

this basic information should be of some help to you in your planning.

we do provide extended warranties and lifetime loaner programs on many mainstream lines.

our clientele is worldwide (22 time zones), so someone is always on call into late evening and through the weekend to answer questions and discuss your application in more detail. call anytime.

thanks again,

formatting link
formatting link

800.549.3832 713.666.5739 (local/international) 713.662.3831 (fax)

Reply to
Mike Stanton

I installed a Whisperkool 8000 to cool a 10x10x10 cellar six years ago. The cellar is on a lower level in Phoenix, AZ and has 2 earth-bermed wall, one common wall to the home, and a fourth that is exterior. The exterior wall faces N and is shielded from any sun by an overhead deck. The walls are super

-insulated with the exterior wall thickness of 10". The unit failed once, very early on and Whisperkool had a replacement in two days. Since then, it has not missed a lick. The unit is one step up for the displacement of the cellar and has maintained 55 +/-1 for these years. I do have to add some humidity, Phoenix being in the Sonoran Desert, but that is mainly for my cigars, as the Whisperkool maintains ~50% year around.

I looked into the Breezaire, but elected to go with the Whisperkool and have been pleased with its preformance. The one problem was handled very quickly and efficiently. They even upgraded the thermo-couple with the replacement unit.

I would never recommend against the Breezaire, especially as I have no experience with that unit.

One caution, is to have a dedicated 20amp electrical mains run to the unit. Do NOT run it from an existing electrical line.

Maybe it is over-engineering to go up one unit size, but AZ, and especially one exterior wall posed concerns for me. If you are using the unit in a totally interior space, and it vents to the interior of an air-conditioned home, I don't know that the sizing-up would be necessary in your case.

I recommend that you take a look at a book, "How and Why to Build a Wine Cellar," by Richard M. Gold Ph.D. It covers a lot, that will not directly effect your decisions, but much that you can draw from. Another source is a Web site (sorry I do not have the URL, but it is close to

formatting link
run by a gentleman named Art Straton [SP?]. Google it and visit. Mr Straton (a contributor to this NG) has an area dedicated to cellar construction. There is also a additional resourse posted in Reply to your article that sounds like a very likely source of info, as well.

Good luck, Hunt

Any questions to hunt @ huntphoto.com (remove spaces at @) Just place Wine Cellar in Subject, please.

Reply to
Hunt

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.