Can a wine cure depression? (with apologies for a bit of a ramble!)

I have not been well lately – a truck & trailer tipped and spilled its 30 ton load of logs on the road in front of the vehicle I was driving. The car was something of a write-off - and so was I.

Physical wounds (broken arm; busted shoulder etc.) can be fixed, but the emotional scars – the loss of the “confidence of invincibility” do not readily heal. In all my 66 years (and I have been through my share of illness) I have never experienced depression – but for the past couple months I have truly been “the sad man, behind blue eyes”

Ten days ago, everything came to a head – I lost two very good friends, both a couple years younger than I, on the same day (deaths totally unrelated).

I seriously dislike funerals where the collective grief pervades like a fog: I usually choose to excuse myself. However, both these funerals were "must attends" and both proved uplifting. The first was a traditional "tangi" to farewell a respected member of the Maori community, the second service, 24 hours later, was an amazing celebration of a life well lived by a larger-than-life businessman.

My spirits lifted, on my way home, I made a decision - that my current life of misery was a waste of emotion. I decided that my "rebirth" would be celebrated with a very simple “feast for one”.

I settled upon a piece of aged scotch fillet (boneless rib-eye to Americans) – rubbed with evo oil, black pepper and sea salt, pan fried, served with asparagus and freshly prepared potato salad.

I am not one who does notes or reviews – I enjoy the savouring and love closing my eyes remembering the nuances and flavours of a wonderful wine, but find it difficult to put these thoughts into words.

I do not possess a dedicated wine cellar – the few bottles I have collected I keep in an insulated “chilly bin”.

2-3 three years ago, I did a favour for an associate, which saved his son’s job (we unionists can be very persuasive :-) As a “thank you” I was presented with a single bottle of Italian wine, at the time, unknown to me: when I originally saw the word “Casanova” on the label, I thought “uh huh”!

But there is nothing “uh huh” about 2001 Casanova di Neri Brunello di Montalcino Cerretalto.

I did not decant: I started the first glass while preparing my meal, I had the last a little over two hours later (yes, I consumed the entire contents alone, with a DVD of Pete Townsend, Roger Daltry et al for company)

Was this an epiphany? No! More a symphony with so many elements - ripe berryfruit / cherry flavours; unobtrusive tannins, decent acid with some wonderful subtle spicy nuances (during that last glass, while laying back in a sort of splendid stupor I even “got” roasted coffee bean, dipped in dark chocolate!)

Was this the best wine I have ever had? I don't know - my memory is not that good. But this would rank right there as one of the most memorable red wines (I do particularly recall a 1990 Dom. Santa Duc “Haute Garriques” Gigondas).

I am not suggesting that Sangiovese possesses some miraculous restorative qualities – but next day, I ventured to the beach for my first swim of 2013 (hey, it is summer here downunder), and have also since returned to work.

My neck and shoulder are still painful – but the associated gloom and doom has gone.

Thank you signore Neri – your wonderful wine has brought me back from the edge.

Reply to
st.helier
Loading thread data ...

I am sure I speak for everybody when I say firstly how sorry I am that you have had one of those patches which do seem to occur, even in the luckiest of lives, from time to time. Much as I would love to believe the reverse, I suspect it is not the wine which has cured, or at least substantially lifted, your depression but your determination to try to move out of the misery. That having been said I do remember last year drinking a bottle of Figeac 1990 on the first anniversary of my mother‘s death and finding the memory of how much she had enjoyed sharing other bottles of the same case to be a cheering, rather than sorrow-making, experience so perhaps wine can help at least.

May I wish you every joy of your recovery from this bad period, both in body and in spirit and offer my sincere hopes that this year will be better for you. (PS Speaking professionally I hope you have good advice as to the accident; to an English lawyer it sounds to be one of those rare beasts — a cast iron case.)

Tim Hartley

Reply to
Tim Hartley

More than just sorry to hear of your accident! I've always appreciated your advice on New Zealand wine and also the guide you once sent me.

All I can say is, Get Well Soon!

Reply to
James Silverton

Andrew, Are we going to have to arrange a group expedition to the Antipodes to coordinate your rescue? It would be a noble undertaking. Never the less you seem to be recovering on your own so perhaps the expedition might be placed in abeyance. As to the depression curative powers of wine-it is not the wine but the man who rises from adversity, the wine merely helps to reaffirm the goodness of life.

For what it is worth 1990 Gigondas is a high order to fill, there was some might fine Rhone wine produced from 88 to 90. What we all wouldn't give to get those bottles back for a reprise.

Take care. We will arrange for a mass singing of the Internationale in your honor :-)

If ever we get back to your lovely country (and home to that man without a country-Country star Keith Urban) we hope to find you fully recovered, I want another shot a dinner at A Deco even if it won't be the bargain we last enjoyed.

Joe and Bev

Reply to
jcoulter

I'm missing the reference here, but he doesn't sound like a prisoner of starvation to me.

And Andrew, I'll add my good wishes for a speedy recovery.

Reply to
Ken Blake

Hope you stayed away from the great whites. Loved your country. One of the most beautiful places I have ever been.

Reply to
lleichtman

e most beautiful places I have ever been.

And sorry to hear about your unfortunate run of bad luck. May that be all.

Reply to
lleichtman

Tim summed up more eloquently than I could. I'm sorry for your travails and losses, but glad things have looked up a little. Thanks for thoughts on the wine, and good wishes for a full recovery.

Reply to
DaleW

Ditto from here, I hope you've already witnessed the brink of happier times.

Reply to
Emery Davis`

a bit of a jibe at His Lordship the Union Boss.

Reply to
jcoulter

Thanks. I didn't know he was a union boss. It's much easier to understand now. So perhaps he's not just a prisoner of starvation, but also among the wretched of the earth (yes, I know the song, but mostly because of my father, not because of my own views).

Reply to
Ken Blake

And, if you'll forgive my further off-topic post, I'm reminded of the book I liked very much,"A Fine Old Conflict" (her mishearing of the words "a Final Conflict" in the song) by Jessica Mitford.

Reply to
Ken Blake

Trom what I understand NZ has about abolished the tort as a personal cause of action in favor of the state. If you are injured in NZ (at least as a visitor) and you get care your rights to sue are transfered tothe government who are empowered to sue first of all for their losses and secondly for any derivative recovery on the part of the injured.This is definitely not the US where a cup of coffee buys you a piece of McDonalds.

Reply to
jcoulter

Tim summed up more eloquently than I could. I'm sorry for your travails and losses, but glad things have looked up a little. Thanks for thoughts on the wine, and good wishes for a full recovery.

Reply to
Anders.Torneskog

"jcoulter" wrote .........

< NZ (at least as a visitor) and you get care your rights to sue are

You are close, Joe.

State owned Accident Compensation Corporation is the sole and compulsory provider of accident insurance for all work and non-work injuries, for residents and visitors alike.

When the scheme was set up back in 1974, the individual lost the right to sue.

In my case, medical costs have been covered and loss of income for the time off work has been covered.

The car was a leased vehicle (covered by insurance) so, monetarily speaking, I have suffered no personal loss.

Many thanks to all for your best wishes - I drink to your good health (say he trying desperately to get something wine related into the post to provide a modicum of on-topic discussion)

I do have a request - for advice.

As the northern hemisphere swings towards spring, we downunder are being warned of the dangers of an influenza epidemic this coming winter.

For us in the older age bracket, we are being offered free influenza shots.

I have never been so immunised in the past, but because of my "tender" disposition of late, I am considering being jabbed this year.

As health issues in northern climes often transport themselves south, can anyone within this forum advise - Just how bad was influenza "up there" this past winter.

Part of me says I have never needed them in the past - leave well alone, but there is this niggling doubt that, if things are bad, then I would be foolish not to avail myself of this free offering.

Anyone in wine-land with any experiences you can share?

Again, thanks for the kind wishes.

st.helier

Reply to
st.helier

I have once again thought about and failed to get a flu shot. So far it hasn't affected my life. There was a lot of it going around in December and with my daily contact with kids in high school (at least this year it has bee that way) I did have a fear of getting it and thought it might happen, but it passed. Some of us are just too pig headed to take the help offered . . . but so far, like you, I have been safe.

just my .02 JC

Reply to
jcoulter

I do recommend the influenza and I sometimes play at being a physician.

Reply to
lleichtman

Get it!!! An otherwise healthy lady died here from H1N1 this winter and the vaccine included this as well as a couple of others. I started getting it every winter about 4 years ago (I'm 69). Like you, I usually went many, many years without being affected but, due to the looming financial year end, I am usually overloaded with work and can't afford to take the time off. Incidentally, and this is anecdotal, I've known people who have had the flu and are so depressed afterwards that they have had to get medical help. Graham

Reply to
graham

beautiful post! my cure to depression was this amazing brunello di montalci no

formatting link

Il giorno venerdì 8 marzo 2013 08:09:25 UTC+1, st.helier ha scritto:

Reply to
piter

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.