hydropnic viticulture and terroir

I saw a web site recently featuring hydroponically grown grapes. It's not popular. But where practiced, hydroponic viticulture has been successful. In Israel, for example. Hydroponic viticulture breaks away from the traditional definition of terroir. I've never tasted hydroponically grown wine (yet), but am wondering what the view is towards its relationship with the earth. Fact is, with total control of nutrients, there may advancement towards a guaranteed successful vintage. Or, is the concept going to end up in the same status as zirconium diamonds? Does that take all the fun out of terroir? Or, is it a step towards saving the art of viticulture from the ravages of global warming? Thoughts?

Jeff

Reply to
jeff
Loading thread data ...

successful. In

towards a

I've heard of one backyard grower that does hydroponic grapes and he is happy with the quality but I'm not sure this is financially feasible on a large scale. You still need the land to grow the grape and I think the cost of equipment would overcome any benefits (if there are any).

I also don't think this would overcome vintage variations. You still need the sun to shine at the right times to make great wines.

Hydroponics really hasn't caught on for other agricultural products, I don't know way it would for grapes.

Just MHO,

Andy

Reply to
JEP62

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.