March Brown Bag Notes

Apr 09, 2004 5 Replies

Notes from a monthly blind tatsing:


2000 Au Bon Climat Sant Ynez Chardonnay Mt. Carmel Vineyard - light straw colour, a fair bit of oak evident in the nose, smooth, supple and elegant in the mouth.


1996 Casa Lapostolle Merlot Cuvee Alexandre - I wanted to see what a few years had wrought with this one. Medium colour, rather nice nose with some green pepper, sweet in the mouth with good length and black pepper on palate, the fruit ripe. The nose added a bit of complexity as it opened up. Do not hold.


1983 Jaboulet Hermitage La Chapelle - the colour on this wine is definitely showing age, and the mushroom nose may be evidence of the same. Good body, a little astringent in the finish, and drying. Drink up!


1997 Dom. de Trevallon - located between Arles and Avignon, this Provençal producer has made what are arguably some of the most interesting wines from the region. Made from 50% cabernet and 50% Syrah (only in Australia, you thought?), it was dark, with both vinyl and mint in the nose, a bit hot in the mouth (but not in the nose), and offered ripe flavours, with some grip. Interesting wine that drinks well now, but I'd like to see what a couple more years do to it.


1995 Les Cailloux Chateauneuf du Pape - a waxy unusual nose featuring capsicum followed by a sweet impression on palate, on the lean side of the spectrum, but with lots of stuffing. Oddly, the berry fruit comes in late, right at the end of the long finish - maybe it is just echoing an earlier appearance that was masked by other impressions? Time to find one of my cases and start sampling this.


1991 Dominus - again, a dark wine, with a sweet nose of fruit and earth. Lots of concentration, sweet very long finish. I was fooled into thinking this a French wine. Very good.


1997 Gallo Frei Ranch Cabernet - mixed rubber and black currant fruit in the nose, sweet entry with lots of tannin. Big concentrated wine with lots of stuffing, but the nose didn't agree with everyone.


1997 Hedges Red Mountain Reserve - this entry from Washington State reprised the rubber we found in the nose of the Gallo, had a blast of fruit, but then chopped off with a short, tannic finish - most of it was poured out by the tasters. Don't know what was going on here!


2001 Osoyoos Larose - this one was interesting - a joint venture between Vincor International Inc., a large operator in Canada (they bought R.H. Phillips and Hogue Cellars), and Gruaud Larose (Group Taillan). Not yet officially released, this wine is from a so-so vintage and is made from a blend of 66% Merlot, 25% Cab Sauv and 9% Cab Franc. Olive and sweet cherry in the nose, fair bit of fruit and lots and lots of tannin, I found this wine to be unbalanced and wonder if they were trying to reprise a 1975 Bordeaux. Will it ever come into balance? Will there still be fruit when the tannins have abated? Do we care? Hopefully they will do better with subsequent vintages.


2001 Quails Gate Old Vines Foch - undoubtedly the best example of this wine I've tasted. Dark with good fruit based nose, good weight in the mouth, ending with both tannin and a final sweet note.


1983 Ch. d'Arche - dark amber in colour, not much Botrytis (unusual in this vintage), sweet and pretty well balanced. The structure was a bit off for me to have guessed it was an 83. Decent but not as rich as many 83s.

Your tasting notes for the 1983 Jaboulet La Chapelle remind me that I have a bottle or two of it that I need to taste soon according to your notes and those by Broadbent in his recent book. I recently had a bottle of the 1982 that was still holding very well. Broadbent also liked this better than the 83, but he has not tasted it in a long time. It is interested that many rate 83 above 82 for much of the Rhone in general. If you had believed the hype when both the 82 and 83 were new on the market, you would have bought only 83. I usually try to buy a variety of decent vintages rather than just one, since surprises can always happen in the long term.

I tasted and then bought 1982 (still have a few bottles of the La Chapelle - first person to open one has to post notes) instead of 1983. Guess my taste (and Broadbent) was right as far as longevity, anyway.

I had the 1982 La Chapelle last year at a tasting.

I remember it being full of exotic spices, sage, plums, mature fruit, absolutely fantasitic to drink. Good balance of tannins and acidity, I think it is almost perfect to drink right now. I wouldn't imagine it getting better though it will probably be a few more years before it begins to slide down. It really stood out for me in a night where I tasted 88 La Turque, 82 Mouton+Lafite, 89 Bordeaux's and much more. A really great wine.

Very interesting notes on the 2001 Osoyoos Larose. I'll be attending the launch for it next week here in Toronto; winemaker and principals from both Taillan and Vincor will be in attendance to do a structured tasting.

I'm curious to see how it will be received; I'll try and post my notes as I have a busy tasting week next week. For some reason, the three wine clubs I'm a member of have their tastings all scheduled for the same week in April. Thus I'll be tasting 1998 CdP, 1990 Cdp, and Sicilian Nero d'Avola on consecutive nights. It's a rough life ;-)

Peter

______________________________________

formatting link
054-4042D64C-11%40storefull-3175.bay.webtv.net&rnum=1______________________________________

The above gives my TN for the 82 Hermitage from February. In case the link does not work, just go to Google groups and search on "cwdjrxNOSPAM Hermitage" .

formatting link
054-4042D64C-11%40storefull-3175.bay.webtv.net&rnum=1

And I replied with my note on the wine as well.

Deja vua all over again. -Yogi Berra

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required