New Closure Capsule Encounters

Dec 18, 2010 6 Replies

Hey gang. I haven't been around in a while, but thought this would be the place for some straight info on my recent frustrations.



I've recently encountered some diabolical new "dip" method of creating a seal capsule. The traditional lead foil is seldom encountered anymore, particularly on American wines. A shrink-wrap sort of closure is common and not problematic.



In the last couple of months I've run into some California bottlings that are using a wax dip, sort of like the candle wax simulation you find on Maker's Mark bourbon. I can still deal with it, although it tends to be messy and crumbling when trying to slice a portion off to access the cork.



The frustration comes from what apparently is a plastic sealant. This looks at first glance like a wax dip but when it comes to opening time, the stuff is nearly impervious to simple tools. It will not slice with a foil cutter or a standard waiter's friend corkscrew knife blade. It doesn't yield to a high quality, sharp santoku. Eventually it must be chopped to break an entry hole which then must be pried away in quarter inch chunks before an opening to get at the cork is revealed.



California syrah was the wine. Napa valley was the region. The wine was reasonably good, but the effort to get at it might it something to avoid in the future. I'd really love to see a sommelier at a quality restaurant deal with the damnable things.



Anybody seen this? Any technique recommendations? Ed Rasimus Fighter Pilot (USAF-Ret)

formatting link



Well, I think we can confidently say we don't see ANY lead capsules (at least in bottles less than 20 years old) With wax seals, I generally just try to go straight thru and pull out cork. Not sure I've seen this harder plastic fake wax. Good to see you here in any case

I've learned to pull straight through the wax versions. I tried that method with this new polymer armor capsule and can't even start the screw.

As for port tongs, as suggested, that seems a bit exceesive for a $15-20 bottle at home for dinner. Maybe the champagne saber thing could work?

Ed Rasimus Fighter Pilot (USAF-Ret)

formatting link

On Dec 18, 6:05 pm, Ed Rasimus wrote: . Maybe the champagne saber thing

Please don't try. I think without pressure you'll not have much luck doing cleanly. It's all about the pressure inside (you know you can "saber" a Champagne bottle with a teaspoon).

DaleW wrote on Sat, 18 Dec 2010 16:36:28 -0800 (PST):

Perhaps you could do it but it seems unlikely. Even using a real saber would worry me. I find it hard to believe that I would not end up swallowing bits of glass!

Believe me, it's quite doable. There's a restaurant in Soho where the owner loves to do it. He loves his teaspoon sabering so much that I quickly opened conventionally the one bottle of good vintage that I brought before he could see it, to save that couple ounces that flows out with sabrage (with NV happy to let him play). Any hard utensil will do, You are not cutting bottle, merely hitting weak spot where seam meets lip - the internal pressure is what causes the pop off.

Ed wrote on Mon, 20 Dec 2010 12:46:26 -0600:

I've seen some weird capsules including hard waxy materials and very tough plastics. Fortunately, the wineries seem to get the message and stop using them without being sued by bleeding customers. As you say, I go for Stelvins and wine using them seems to keep well.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required