Much appreciated, thanks for such a comprehensive reply.
Much appreciated, thanks for such a comprehensive reply.
Thanks Bob for a succinct and readable offering of introductory wine advice! Maybe it belongs in an FAQ list (right after "how and how not to use newsgroups." -- I lately assembled a very terse summary of the latter for some email correspondents, for example).
If I might put forward one or two related observations from my own perspective --
"RobertsonChai" in news: snipped-for-privacy@mb-m15.aol.com...
I don't believe that this point can be over-emphasized. Wine merchants have a literally ancient tradition of seeking out wines and making the public aware of them. They tend strongly to be wine hobbyists themselves. Wine merchants, whose livelihood depends on satisfying their customers with actual wine rather than, for example, on selling publications, have historically composed (or so one of them, Coates, wrote) most of the people to pass the notoriously difficult British Master-of-Wine examination (when I had the numbers a decade ago, there were 13 MWs in North America and two of them near me both worked in retail, although one of those, Peter Marks, ended up at the Coppia center/museum in Napa).
This may surprise observers of large US labels like K-J, Meridian, and Fetzer (AFTER its founding family was bought out by a vast wine-spirits conglomerate). It is easy to condclude that large manufacturers are in the business of returning profit to their shareholders. This, in turn, favors catering to a broad public and if reaching out to the many people in places like the US who do not traditionally drink wine. Bob however then adds
Though some unnecessary "pain" has traditionally come accidentally to people who reach to wines of high reputation and find them off-puttingly bitter only because they are being opened at once whereas intended for five or ten years of cool aging first.
Finally in contrast to "mellow," a trend _after_ the 1970s, which some consider unfortunate too, was summarized once as follows. The population that pays attention to, and describes wine centrally by, numerical scores in publications is a specific and recent segment of the fine-wine-consuming public. (Some of that segment appears unaware of this.) The very process of following such scores distorts, demonstrably, both prices and winemaking. (Veterans will have noted the absence of recommending this seductive, saccharine path as an implicit cue of wisdom and experience in Bob's advice.)
My dreigrosschen worth. (With due respect to Kurt Weill.) -- Max the Knife
Well so far I've been tryin Santa Rita 120 Sauvignon Blanc, Santa Rita 120 Merlot, and some Faustino V Reserva all of which have been nice the Sauvignon Blanc would be my personal favourite. The Faustino had a little bit of the pain factor mentioned but as I got through the bottle I began to take a shine to it. It was only just over 35 euros for the 3 bottles aswell which was grand.
Would anyone have a recommendation of a nice Rose to get my hands on?? Anything up to about 30 euros.
Cheers again, Ronan
DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.