With tonight's dinner of roast chicken, I opened:
2009 Causse Marines Marcillac nose: initially, grapey/carbonic macercation, pepper; later turning smoky with graphite notes palate: fleshy, balanced acidity, medium body, smooth tannins
The previous edition of this wine (the '08) was one of my wines of the year in 2010. This year's version is fleshier and more full-bodied, though still not a ponderous or heavy wine. Also, the more herbaceous qualities of last year's wine were not much in evidence in the '09. In both years I got a resemblance to Cab Franc, but whereas the '08 called to mind the Cab Francs of the Loire, the '09 puts me in mind of St. Emilion with its more torrefactive notes. Still lovely, but I'm keeping my second bottle of this in the cellar to see how it develops with time.
Mark Lipton