TN: 375s of Bandol and Pauillac, bubbles, Mencia, Gamay, Chablis, etc

Feb 26, 2019 Last reply: 7 years ago 5 Replies

On Friday a couple of wines with dinner (pork/soba/snap pea stir fry)



1998 Nigl Privat Piri Riesling Stony and dry, grapefruit, slate. Mature but really tasty. A-/B+


1985 Pichon-Lalande (375) A wine I?ve liked before a lot but was hoping holding on in half. Nose was a little funky and sour at first, but brightened. Cassis, pencil shavings, tobacco, and herbs. Resolved tannins and totally mature in this format, but elegant and delicious. A-



Saturday I got some lemon sole from fishmonger at farmers market, Betsy prepared plus potatoes, broccoli rabe, & salad



2016 Barat Cote de Lechet Chablis 1er Tasty almost tropical fruit, decent acids, good length, more Chardonnay than Lechet. B/B-

Sunday we ignored the Oscars and had some friends (and one dog) as guests



Cheese coins (like cheese straws, a Gabrielle Hamilton recipe) and duck breast/hummus/radish canapes NV Godme Extra Brut Champagne At first this was a little too austere for me but I adjusted my expectations. Pear, apple, and a little vanilla, good length and depth, not much in the bready/yeasty line but intriguing. B+



Chicken with clementines, fennel, and Pernod (Ottolenghi recipe was actually for arak but didn?t have), brown rice, salad



2015 Castro Candaz ?A Boca do Demo? (Ribeira Sacra) A Raul Perez project (with a partner), old vines, field blend of Mencia with some Trousseau and Grenache. Young,spicy/peppery, crunchy raspberry and red cherry, herbs. Long and structured but offering pleasure. B+/A-


2016 Jules Burdin Beaujolais-Villages New producer to me, Straightforward, sweet red cherry and plum, modest finish. B-



Monday I took Betsy to a (very belated) birthday dinner at Vaucluse on Upper East Side. She started with the crab salad (apples, elderflower gelee, trout roe) while I had grilled octopus with teeny potatoes, carrot romesco, and pickled carrot. Then her primi was risotto with funky maroilles cheese, pear, & hazelnut (latter 2 ingredients were a nice crunchy contrast to creamy risotto), mine was rabbit & reblochon cheese ravioli with black truffle jus.A couple of glasses with those:



La Taille aux Loups 'Brut Tradition' Montlouis-sur-Loire I?ve had Jacky Blot?s non dosage before, this shows quite different. Fuji apple, some citrus bloom, easy mousse. B


2017 Foucher 'Les Ponts Romains' Sancerre OK, quite grassy, good with food but not much depth. B-/C+

My main was dry-aged duck breast with quinoa (baby beets & kumquat), hers lamb chops, with honeynut squash, cipollini onion, and spiced pear


2013 Terrebrune Bandol (375) Black plum, blackberries, some herb. Very ripe, like a dark-fruited CdP, good but a bit more heft than my ideal for the meal, but I thought best choices of the halves. B/B+ She finished with a beautiful lemon eclair with ice cream, I had some cheese-NY Tumbleweed, Point Reyes Bay Blue, Epoisses.

Delicious meal if not a wine memory.



Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C drinkable. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice.Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.


So, you got me thinking and I pulled out a 750 for tonight. See if we match up. My last one was a definite A.

I've got a couple of these in the cellar. Will have to pull one soon and maybe put it up against a Huet Petillant Reserve that I've also got.

The food at Vaucluse sounds fabulous, BTW. I hope that Betsy enjoyed her birthday dinner as much as I enjoyed reading about it (a belated happy birthday to her, BTW -- I'll join her at that watershed number in June)

Mark Lipton

I liked the Blot, just different from the Triple Zero Actually you get to landmark celebration first, Betsy is not till Dec, this was a VERY belated dinner (her birthday was in Dec, I gave her a list of restaurants and told her to choose one and date, took 2+ months). So her big one is this December

Very tight. Took 3 hours to open up. Very herbal nose with some dark fruit and a little bit of cinnamon spice. Dry tannins that really didn't resolve until the second day. On day 2 much more open and delicious. Would give this an easy A- and still enjoying it on day 3 as my wife can't drink much right now. Glad I have two more.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required