TN: 4th of July Wines and an OT Weinerfest

Jul 05, 2005 3 Replies

For the 4th we had a variety of friends over. We made some marinated London broil, grilled veggies (sweet potatoes, squash, etc), mango salsa, and a few other things. Friends brought a variety of salads and desserts. We had a Frankfurter Challenge (see below if interested), where the Hebrew National edged a local weiner from a farmer's market (they were well-ahead of other contenders). The petanque game never started, though the badminton progressed well.



We didn't have red, white and blue wines, but we did manage red, white,and pink:



Red:


2004 Andre Iché "Les Hérétiques" (VdP de l'Hérault) My first try of the 2004. Juicy, sweet fruit with some lavender and Italian herb notes. Easy to drink and fun, quite the deal at about $7.B/B+


2003 Clos Roche Blanche Cabernet (Touraine) Dark plum fruit, some light herb notes. Reasonable and ready to go, but no need to search for. B


2001 Havens Bourriquot (Napa) Fittingly on July 4th an American wine is my favorite of the day. Big young wine that needs time for the ripe tannins and spicy/toasty oak to integrate. But lovely balance and purity of flavors, long finish, great potential. A/A-


2001 Jadot Beaujolais-Villages I find this much better than I expected. Good acidity, clean cherry fruit, somewhat light but so what. Decent finish. B/B+


2002 Clos del Mas (Priorat) Oakchippy and with some green tannins, very soft and round. Seems somewhat extracted, yet has short finish and is just not for me. C


2002 Escudo Rojo (Chile) This also is a bit oaky, but the fruit is better balanced and the finish clean. Decent. B


1999 La Fleur du Bouard (Lalande de Pomerol) Deep rich lush fruit, some graphite and flowers over the bed of deep black fruits. The oak is still a bit unintegrated, this could use another 1-2 years IMHO but is pretty good now. Ripe tannins, long finish. A-


2001 Domaine des Relagnes Côtes du Rhône Vieilles Vignes Pleasant straightforward CdR, some ripe red fruit and Provencal herbs. There's some light but gritty tannins in the back that bother me a little, I might try holding my remaining bottle(s) a couple years and hope the fruit holds out. B



White:



2004 Domaine de la Pepiere Muscadet Is there anything left to say about this? My favorite under$10 wine of the summer to date. A- (solid A+ for value)


2003 Hawk's Crest Chardonnay (second label of Stag's Leap Wine Cellars) Light-bodied Chardonnay, a touch of butter on some modest pear fruit. A bit soft and maybe a touch-offdry, but ok. B/B-



Pink:


2004 Domaine de Chevalier Rosé Another rosé from a prestigious Bordeaux estate. This is simple fruit juice, like the Monbousquet it leaves me cold. C+


2002 Reserve de Vignerons Cabernet de Saumur Pleasant enough co-op rosé, light strawberry fruit over some floral accents. A little short on the finish, and maybe a bit tired. B-


2004 Robert Sinskey Vin de Gris de Pinot Noir (Napa) Strawberries, peaches, and honeysuckle on the nose, nicely crisp yet plenty of fruit. Best rosé of the day (I had a bottle of Il Mimo out, but it eventually traveled to the house where we watched fireworks and I never tasted). B+/A-

Afterwards we went to watch fireworks over the Hudson. Nice Independence Day.


Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency



Purpose of study: To investigate and research the relative popularity of a variety of frankfurters available in the New York metro area in a head-to-head format.

The Weiners: 9 dogs were chosen for the competition. Natural casing beef : Dynes Farms, Nathan's, Wellshire Farms, Boar's Head, Papaya King, Sabrett's, Fairway Kosher: Empire National, Hebrew National Turkey, Pork & Chicken: Oscar Mayer Weiner Some Intellig-Dogs/Tofu Pups arrived too late to be part of the judging. Attempts were made to include Lobel's and Schaller and Weber, but time constraints kept the author from the Upper East Side. It should be noted the the Oscar Meyer entry was supposed to be the Beef Frank, somehow the author grabbed the wrong package. '

Methodology: A pool of 25+ potential tasters were lured to a backyard on July 4th with promises of free food, wine, beer, and juice. Tasters ranged from 4 to about 64 in age.

3 of each wiener were grilled, and sliced into 6-7 portions. Test was not blind, each plate was labeled. Judges were asked to try and get any condiments consistent across the contestant franks. Attempts were made to grill one dog lightly, one medium, and one with a good char to allow each taster to choose according to their preference. Tasters were given score sheets with each dog, with possible ratings of 1 (poor), 2 (OK), 3 (good), 4 (very good) or 5 (bodaciously great). 15 tasters filled out sheets, although several missed one or two franks. After scoring, each taster could order more of the frank of their choice.

Results: In a pretty tight race, Hebrew National edged Dynes Farms (Hudson Valley product attained at a farmer's market). Final average scores were:

Hebrew National 3.86 (54 points, 14 voters) Dynes Farms 3.69 (48/13) Nathan's 3 (42/14) Wellshire Farms 2.85 (40/14) Boar's Head 2.71 (38/14) Empire National 2.64 (37/14) Papaya King 2.64 (37/14) Sabrett's 2.61` (34/13) Fairway 2.46 (32/13) Oscar Mayer 1.85 (26/14)

A few notes from the study's author: While time and financial restraints prevent us from doing an intense statistical analysis including standard deviation, a few points seem to be obvious from the scoresheets:

1) Some voters have distinct preferences for casing vs. no casing 2) Sabretts & Wellshire Farms seem to cause the greatest variance of opinions, they are the only franks to have scored both 1s & 5s. 3) Papaya King, Hebrew National, and Dyne's Farms had no 1 scores. 4) No scorer rated Oscar Meyer above 3.

The author makes no representation that this study is in any way indicative of quality. As a matter of fact, the author only ranked 2 dogs as "4", the Boar's Head and the Empire National. He ranked the top 2 vote-getters both as a 3.

Dale

Dale, the best dog in the country is a White Hot from Rochester NY. The Brand name is Zweigles.

Best of class!!!1

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required