TN: NYS wines (plus 1 Niagara)

Jun 04, 2018 5 Replies

Local group met, theme being NY State and Canadian wines. Fred hosted, put out salmon spread, hummus, and tapenade; later he grilled sausage and chick en


2017 Salmon Run (Dr. K. Frank) Rose (Finger Lakes) Soft, edge of sweetness, red fruits. B-/C+

Rest were blind


2017 One Woman Rose (North Fork) A bit crisper than the FL rose (would have guessed other way around), herby . B-


2016 One Woman Gruner Veltliner (North Fork) Moderate acids, pear and citrus, not very Gruner ish but tasty. B


2015 Norman Hardy Chardonnay (Niagara ) Buttery oak, vanilla, modest acids, big but short. I though NF Chard C+


2015 Duck Walk Pinot Grigio (Hamptons) A wine to make you appreciate Sta. Marg. Low acid, sweet, short. C+


2014 Eminence Road “Elizabeth’s Vineyard” Cabernet Franc (Finger Lakes) Mine, had some time in decanter. Raspberry green tobacco and herbs, balance d and fun. B+


2015 Hearts and Hands Pinot Noir (Finger Lakes) Fresh, crisp cherry, some herbs. B+/B


2014 Onabay Cabernet Franc (North Fork) Light, acids a little disjointed, but some nice cranberry fruit. B-


2015 Eminence Road “Elizabeth’s Vineyard” Cabernet Sauvignon (Finger Lakes) Soft cassis, some herb. I guessed NF Merlot B/B-



There was a terrible Merlot, but I didn’t write down name. Somehow I thought someone said it was Pinot Project, but that makes no sense.



Fun night, though I would have preferred if there wasn’t a downpour during walk home



Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C drinkable. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a p arty where it was only choice.Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivi ty, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.


We are going to a Society of Wine Educators in Rochester then on to the Finger Lakes for wine touring. Not too impressed with this set of wines.

I think if you are in FL and concentrate on Riesling (and maybe Cab Franc for reds), you can do better than this group.

Your group probably has stuff set up, but if not could try Ravines, Wiemer, Dr. K Frank, Forge, Fox Run etc. I do like Eminence Road Farms but their actual winery isn't in FL.

Thanks. We have booked Ravines, Dr. K Frank and Eminence Farms. Will check out the others.

Wow, Eminence Road Farm is a heckuva drive from FL. Say hi to A & J for me

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required