Banana wine... recipe mistake ? (Anderson book)

Nov 27, 2006 4 Replies

I'd like to make a nice white wine for summer. I've made good wines from peaches and apricots. Neither of those fruits are in season right now, but bananas are plentiful and cheap.



The following book has been my bible in making fruit wines.

formatting link
64667737/ref=pd_bbs_sr_7/103-7685839-5323030?ie=UTF8&s=books I found the recipes for peach and apricot wines to work quite well.



On page 102, it has a recipe for banana wine.



The first thing I like is the description. "Bananas make a full bodied wine. Served over ice with a dash of soda water and a slice of lemon, it makes a great tropical cooler." So far so good for a summer wine. The aging time is just about a year, but maybe we can start consuming it a bit young in order to enjoy it in July or so.



Then I look at the recipe and "sequence".



Step #1, paraphrased: chop 12 pounds of ripe sound bananas with peels and mix with 4 quarts of water. Boil for 30 minutes.



Problem: what does chop mean ? Does it mean slice the bananas into 1/2" sections ? Does it mean pulverize like pieces of tomato for a chunky salsa ?



Problem: will 4 quarts of water cover 12 pounds of chopped bananas ?



Step 2 through 8, paraphrased: strain, add vinacid water, sugar (14 pounds !) oranges, yeast,etc. Ferment it.



Problem: the sum total of all the liquids is much less than the 24 liters I would expect. The recipe states 15 liters of water in total and some of that will be lost boiling and straining the bananas. It doesn't say anything about topping up to 24 liters. It also doesn't say what the starting SG should be.



Just to confuse things, here is the same recipe adapted and it calls for



17.5L of liquids.
formatting link


So...



a) has anyone made this wine or one like it ? How did it turn out ? Could you share the recipe ?



b) has anyone been able to contact the authors about corrections for the book ? Or are they published somewhere ?



c) how would you adjust this recipe to make a good wine ? Add additional water to bring it up to the 24 liter mark ?



Thanks.


When I get confusing instructions like this I generally go back to the Internet and find more recipes for the same thing and combine them to make my own recipe.

formatting link
64667737/ref=pd_bbs_sr_7/103-7685839-5323030?ie=UTF8&s=books

Have not tried it myself me2.

If you take a look at the link that you supplied. it states in 11 & 13 to top up with water.

Hope this helps.

Brian

Sounds like a rather careless recipe. A lot are like that. I really get turned off when they say nothing about SG or Brix.

Banana wine is noted as being full bodied and not descript. It is used a lot to add body to other wines. I havenever had it by itself but wort a try. If it is not overly impressive, keep it for blending.

Another good alternative for off season winewmaking is Welch's frozen concnetrates. I have made the Niagara using Jack Keller's recipe and it has turned out very nice. It is ready to drink in only about 3 months but I think it starts declining after 12 mothns so do not plan on aging it long.

It also is a good wine to a vinuosity to fruit wines. It might be worth while to make a Niagara/Banana blend. Just an additional thought to confuse you with. ;o)

Ray

formatting link
64667737/ref=pd_bbs_sr_7/103-7685839-5323030?ie=UTF8&s=books

I made 6 gallons of bananna wine about 4 years ago. It was good but too sweet. I errored by not realizing they have a goodly amount of sugar. It took about 18 months for it to mellow. It was a good desert wine because of the sweetness.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required