Well, I came home to a package from Upton's which contained among other things one of each of their Pu-Erh's so I could have a second go at it after a bad first impression a few years back. I know that these are far from the best Pu-Erh has to offer, but I had to start somewhere and was still a bit aprehensive from my first bout.
I started with their China Tuo Cha. I have to admit upon first smell it brought back bad memories. I got my water to ~212degrees, and did my initial rinse. Then began the brewing. The aroma still had me a bit skeptical, and the first sip was pretty shaky because I had to get past the old thoughts of mouldy/dirt tastes, the second sip I really was trying and was having trouble seeing how so many people (and here) can so highly follow this stuff, but by the third sip I was loving every drop of it! While it had a mild flavor, with a hint of possibly mushroom, the finish was unmistakably sweet and very good. There were no smoky hints, or cigar notes at all which is fine by me. By the bottom of my cup I had a strange sensation, almost as if I had drank a small glass of wine. I felt relaxed and ready for a second brewing. The second brewing was no different than the first taste-wise. I am now about to go have my third go at it, and I think I may be hooked... or at least my initial experience is a distant memory now and I'm ready to come at this again.
I want to thank everyone here who has offered insight into Pu-Erh, and of course pu-erh.net, I never would have stepped back in the water after my first try without it all. My wallet may not be so thankful, but my fiance really enjoyed it as well and she is not really heavily into tea as I am so I won't have to justify any expenses at least.
- Dominic Drinking: Pu-Erh... whodathunkit.