Cellaring Rasteau

I know this sounds like a film title ("Educating Rita" or some 'nother drivel), but inquiring minds want to know whether these can be cellared and appreciated with age on them. Case at hand: yesterday, I opened a Dom. Soumade 'cuvee Confiance' 1999. I first had this in 2002 and it was as you would expect, full of primary black fruits and big in a New World way. I thought it had the stuffing to continue 5-8 years no problem but then the bottle last night found the fruit fading, alcohol predominant, without any secondary transformations going on. I'm wondering if this will survive 'the Cellar test'? Luckilly I only have 1 more bottle to donate to science, but it makes me wonder: this is pretty much the same blend (grenache, syrah, mourvedre) that goes into Chateauneuf-du-Pape and Gigondas, so how come they can age much more gracefully than Rasteau? Or does fault lie with the producer?

Mark S

Reply to
<mjsverei
Loading thread data ...

We're talking CdRV Rasteau, not the fortified stuff, right? I don't have any experience with this particular wine. But I do wonder whether this could just be a sign of shutting down- a phenomenon pretty characteristic of CdP. I try to drink most CdP from good vintages very young (4 or less years from cintage) or more than 10. YMMV. best, Dale

Dale Williams Drop "damnspam" to reply

Reply to
Dale Williams

: Generally Rasteau produces big, deep, hot, generous wines with lots of : jammy fruit as appreciated by RP. (Interesting aside: just ran across : a copy of RP's '87 guide to the Rhone while browsing through boxes. : In Rasteau he mentions _only_ the coop as being of "excellent quality!" : It is a good coop, but far from the best in the village, even back then.) : They are best appreciated young or after 10 or more years. They do, : as Dale suggests, tend to shut down somewhat, but not as much as : a Chateauneuf IMHO.

Emery (and Dale), this could be and I'm going to let that last bottle sit for awhile longer. There was just such a difference between 2 years that I was afraid that, like many an RP-loved wine, the alcohol would dominate a thin frame of a wine. I bought this on closeout for $19, so I don't feel Too bad.

But they are worth holding; as the tannins resolve : they turn into some of the very best from the southern Rhone. Not light : praise that!

: La Soumade is certainly a star of the appellation, and typically very ageworthy. : That said, vintages differ, and I didn't taste any of the '99, so it may just : be that this _particular_ confiance won't age well. Time will tell, : please report back in 2010! :) Anyway it is inaccurate to say that : Rasteau doesn't age "gracefully."

Will do, but probably more like 3-4 years. I'd tasted 'dumb' CDP's before. They were closed, but you could tell there was stuffing there. This Soumade I worried about since I couldn't detect fruit or tannin (but this could be the grenache component, since I rarely find grenache to be tannic in the same way other reds can be).

: BTW, I see you are posting from a Sun 4! What a dinosaur, that's the : VME card cage thing, probably about 10 MHz, right? I think I used : one of these long, long ago... SunOS 5.8 seems to remind me of a : _text only_ embedded unix.

You know, I'm not sure, since that's the server that the university runs UNIX on, and I *know* they are not upgrading or putting resources into this, so, yes, it Could be that old!

Thanks for the responses!

Mark S (and Emery, you need to 'delurk' some more! Miss your excellent posting)

Reply to
<mjsverei
[] ] Will do, but probably more like 3-4 years. I'd tasted 'dumb' CDP's before. ] They were closed, but you could tell there was stuffing there. This ] Soumade I worried about since I couldn't detect fruit or tannin (but this ] could be the grenache component, since I rarely find grenache to be tannic ] in the same way other reds can be). ]

Hi Mark,

This is pretty unusual in a Romero wine, it makes me wonder if it's not slightly corked, or a bad bottle in some other way. I've not noticed a lot of bottle variation with La Soumade, but accidents will happen. Or perhaps it was cooked before you got it...

[] ] Thanks for the responses! ]

You're welcome, of course. I couldn't resist a chance to expound on Rasteau. :)

] Mark S (and Emery, you need to 'delurk' some more! Miss your excellent ] posting)

You're too kind, suh. I will perhaps, as time management has never been my strong suite.

-E

Reply to
Emery Davis

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.