Chateau Ste Michelle Cab?

Jun 24, 2005 5 Replies

I am new to wines and have been trying various cabs that are under $15. After doing some research on the web I decided to try the widely recommended Chateau Ste Michelle 2001 Cab. YUK! Its all Tannin and no fruit, its a very raspy wine IMO. Did I get a bad bottle, or are my tastes just out of wack? I had a bottle of Michael Pozzan that I thought was decent. Also had some Santa Ema reserve cab from Chile at a restaraunt that I though was good.



Joel



Ste. Michelle's got some real problems with their reds. Just 10 days ago they announced the hiring of yet another winemaker for their reds, Josh Maloney (formerly of Estancia). Maloney succeeds Bob Bertheau, who was promoted last November to succeed Ron Bunnell, Ste. Michelle red winemaker since 1999. Berteau is now head winemaker. As reported by QRW.com in All Things Grape and Small, Spring 2005:

"Washington state’s Chateau Ste. Michelle winery has promoted Bob Bertheau to head winemaker, with responsibility for both red and white wines. Bertheau had previously been in charge of the company’s white wine program. Ron Bunnell, who had directed red wine making, will now concentrate solely on Col Solare, Ste. Michelle’s joint-venture with the Italian producer Antinori. Curiously, the head winemaker position at Ste. Michelle had been vacant since 1999, when Mike Januick left the job to start his own eponymous winery."

Anybody who's tasted Mike Januik's wines knows the guy has a real talent with reds. I'm not surprised the quality fell at Ste. Michelle when he left.

The Ste. Michelle press releases are at:

formatting link
formatting link
If I'm not mistaken, it was the Wine Spectator a couple months ago that trashed Ste. Michelle's recent reds. "Disappointing" I think was the phrase they used, trying not to be too disparaging of one of their advertisers. If you've got one of those spiffy $50-a-year WS online memberships, you can probably find the article in their archives.

I haven't been a fan of Ste. Michelle reds for a l>I am new to wines and have been trying various cabs that are under $15.

snipped-for-privacy@unspameljefe.net wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com:

Never the less they have some pretty nice whites for the price. Cold Spring Riesling is just a delight with oriental food, not as off dry as the Dr Loosen and a tad richer than the regular Riesling.

Their whites are another story entirely. Tried the Eroica?

It was their 1973 and 1974 rieslings that put them on the map.

JJ

snipped-for-privacy@unspameljefe.net wrote in news:6o0sb1t7s5dit7nuj1oo3ondgtdfik5b57@

4ax.com:

Yes I have had the Eroica, but prefer the cold spring

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required