A very good french friend of mine is cooking some Dolphin fish (Mahi Mahi) with a herby tapenade (anchovies and olives) and pecan to celebrate his son's 30th birthday. Said son lives in Chicago, so Francois is looking for a place to get some suitable wine. I've suggested a not too oaky Chardonnay or a barrel fermented Sauvignon or a top GruVe. Can I ask you for your help in two directions.
1 Any further suggestions as to a suitable wine.
MOST important. What's the best place to visit to get it in Chicago.
I count on your expertise to help. François will probably be reading the NG to collect your thoughts, and reads English well.
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
D
DaleW
Mark L could probably do better, but here's a couple thoughts re stores(based on my mailorder knowledge, I'm no Chicagoan!):
1) Sam's is probably best known Chicago store, very large selection and generally good prices.
2) Binny's is known for good prices, though I've heard questions re storage (but probably not an issue if you're picking a recent vintage).
3) John Hart (now known as something different- Hart-something-Hart) is a good source for older wines, unsure re story with young stuff.
I think you're suggestions are good- big white is definitely way to go. But I think I'd vary a bit- white Rhone would be my choice.
good luck, Francois!
J
jcoulter
Ian Hoare wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com:
To keep with the general tener of the meal, perhaps a Chateauneuf du Pape Blanc?
I
Ian Hoare
Salut/Hi All
I know it's infra dig to reply to your own post!!
Firstly, the subject line is wrong, it should have read
"Urgent. Please help re Chicago area"
le/on Mon, 14 Mar 2005 16:58:55 +0100, tu disais/you said:-
Thanks to all who have replied so far. I have gathered your suggestions and posted them to François, in case he doesn't manage to find a way of reeading us here, and will continue to do so. So please, keep 'em coming.
Many thanks.
S
st.helier
Ian,
I know you may be inclined to think "what the hell would a NZer know about supplies in the Chicago area" - but I must really throw a strong recommendation for Sam's.
The most esteemed Prof. Lipton arranged for a couple of bottles of Zin to be dispatched from Sam's (in Chicago) to myself (in NZ) - and they arrived, in perfect condition, delivered to my office, customs cleared within ***36 hours***!!!!!!!!
That is sensational service in any man's terms - both from the retailer and courier company.
Don't discount mail order (US interstate transshipment laws permitting!!)
M
Mark Lipton
Ian, Sorry for weighing in so late on this topic. Yes, Sam's is the clear leader for selection & price. They have a decent selection of GruVe's at any given moment, a decent selection of NZ SBs, and a good, if pricey collection of wines from Alsace. However, they are a bit weak in their selection of wines from the Loire (IIRC, though, they do have some '02 Huet LHL demi-sec right now). For unoaked Chardonnay, they had
-- and may still have -- a fair number of '02 Chablis from Verget [is it unoaked? I cannot say] and Boudin. As Dale mentioned, another interesting store in Chicago is Hart-Davis-Hart (née John Hart Fine Wines). They started their existence as a dealer in older, grey market wines, but have gradually moved into new releases as well. They usually have a very enticing selection of White Burgundies and White Rhones. If your friend wanted to get a Beaucastal Roussanne V.V., that would be the place I would send him (caveat: this establishment is as far from the usual caviste as one is likely to find; they have office space on the 5th floor of an office tower, with cellars in the lower depths. Visitors to the office see no wine at all and must order online). As for what I'd serve with the fish, the saltiness of the tapenade would steer me to something off-dry, like your top GruVe or a Zind-Humbrecht Pinot Gris (Indice 2-3) or how about a good Provençal rosé?
Relevant hyperlinks:
formatting link
formatting link
HTH Mark Lipton
X
xenophobe
wow - a guy that really OWNED a restaurant in france???? that must make him some kind of celebrity. there are very few places to purchase wine in chicago - 'good thing you planned ahead for such an important event.
if the guy wants to get some in chicago, i'd recommend rush street. if he just wants wine, he might try a wine shop.
X
xyzsch
looking for a
Chardonnay or
Help me out here Ian. A top GruVe? I am not familiar with this, and a google search gives a bunch of garbage about raves.
Thanks
Tom Schellberg
J
jcoulter
" snipped-for-privacy@aol.com" wrote in news:1110854426.313772.228490 @f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com:
Gruner Veltliner, an Austrian white
X
xyzsch
Thanks
I just didn't recognize the abbreviation.
Tom Schellberg
I
Ian Hoare
Salut/Hi snipped-for-privacy@aol.com,
le/on 14 Mar 2005 19:00:59 -0800, tu disais/you said:-
Sorry Tom, it's a barbarism I learnt here. I thought it was current.
By the way... it appears that mother and son have forbidden white. I've suggested that François tells them they're on their own. But if anyone can come up with any suggestion less than frightful, I suppose it would be a kindness.
Sigh.
M
Mark Lipton
Egad! Would they similarly balk at a rosé? If so, then *mumble mumble* Pineau D'Aunis???
Yours sympathetically, Mark Lipton
E
Emery Davis
] Ian Hoare wrote: ] > Salut/Hi snipped-for-privacy@aol.com, ] > ] > le/on 14 Mar 2005 19:00:59 -0800, tu disais/you said:- ] > ] > ] >>Thanks ] >>
] >>I just didn't recognize the abbreviation. ] > ] > ] > Sorry Tom, it's a barbarism I learnt here. I thought it was current. ] > ] > By the way... it appears that mother and son have forbidden white. I've ] > suggested that François tells them they're on their own. But if anyone can ] > come up with any suggestion less than frightful, I suppose it would be a ] > kindness. ] > ] > Sigh. ] ] Egad! Would they similarly balk at a rosé? If so, then *mumble mumble* ] Pineau D'Aunis??? ]
Aha! A coteaux du Loir might not be a bad match. And dark red enough to satisfy the peanut gallery. Otherwise, how about Arbois? Or even a chilled Bourgueil, or (dare I say it) Fleury?
Hmm, all French, they should try something American. What's a good domestic red to reccomend with Mahi Mahi?
-E
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.